scrapdizzy:
I gotta admit, after trying on about 30 different setups today at 3 different Dive Shops....im leaning towards the MARES Dragon. What a great BC and so comfortable! My runner up at this point is the Dive Rite Transpac and travel wing. I was'nt feeling the crotch strap situation though.
Scrapdizzy, I hope you take this post in the spirit intended...
Trying on a BC of any kind in a shop tells you nearly nothing other than the size is grossly too large, far too small, or fits in general. If you didn't take these units in the water, you've learned nearly nothing about them. It's like sitting in car in a showroom, imagining how'd they'd feel on the road, and trying to decide which is right for you.
I will also reiterate that you will spend approximately 1/15 to 1/20 of your dive time on land/boat, and the remainder in the water. How a BC feels on the surface is nearly immaterial. Unless you purchase a BC that fits exceptionally well, the crotch strap plays a very important role that is not apparent until you've taken the unit in the water. Your first time on the surface in the BC will explain why.
Of course, my preference is a hog rigged BP/W. However, I realize that many divers do not like that system. Therefore, I suggest that you try a variety of BCs in the water, before you decide what you really want. Keep note of how much weight you have to wear with each system. Take note of how hard or easy it is to get into a good, horizontal swimming position. Take note of where you would put weights, lights, and your other scuba gear.
Take the unit and pack it in a duffel or roller bag if you plan on traveling with the unit and see how it packs.
Best of luck in your decision.
WWW 
