It is anecdotal and I just went through all the Internet comments and reviews I could. Please can you explain what you would not consider as 'anecdotal' and the practical steps to get such information so it would help OP ?What survey did you use? What was the tally? Did you consider that people tend to post about something when there is an issue, and maybe more suits of one brand are sold?
Your comments seem very anecdotal in nature.
In my case I just had no bad feedback at all for O3 and Otter (just trying to remember from memory). Like you said, it could be just that my sample is not representative. But again, what alternative do I have but to go on available information ?
As always, when giving constructive criticism, you are encouraged to propose a better alternative and methodology to get a proper feedback/survey so it is actually helpful to OP.
You are also entitled to your opinion as well. I already disclaimed in my previous posts that I used only what I could find on internet reviews and forums to make my decision. I also emailed all three and got better and quicker sales information from O3 and Otter than Seaskin.
It does not bother me if you have another experience, but I hope your post is not based on an anectodal evidence of 1
I suggest OP does the same 'research' than I did and, as always, does not trust someone else's opinion. As the russians and Reagan said: 'trust, but verify !'