For the record I have the opinion that many things about Cozumel diving were better after Wilma. But that explains the difference between Ron Lee and I. You see, he believes that "You never see anything interesting in a swim through" and I love the majesty of the huge swim throughs at Punta Sur Sur and Columbia Deep. Of course the waves of Wilma hurt the soft corals and stuff on the 30 foot reefs, but like magic they opened up hundreds of swim throughs at 60-90 ft down south, that had been filled with sand for thousands of years. Indeed, my first trip to Punta Sur Sur after Wilma was a shocker. Didn't recognize the place, I was like a kid in a candy store. A big plus was that all of a sudden we started seeing large groupings of Caribbean Gray Reef sharks which I had never seen there before (starting in 1992).
Ask Ron Lee about the quote above and his forced encounter with a big Caribbean Reef shark in a Punta Sur Sur swim through!
The bottom line is that the hurricane changed things and made some people sad and others very happy...but it was just a natural change. The shallow corals are already coming back strong but the new swim throughs are still wide open--and will be past my last dive!
Dave Dillehay
Aldora Divers