Well, If I had been a few minutes quicker, they would have met the business end of a baseball bat. I know, you probably shouldn't bring a bat to a gun fight, but with my size (6', 280lbs), and the speed that I would have been moving and the element of surprise, they would have been in a sorry state.
Never under estimate the power of the fat guy with the baseball bat, especially when he opens up a can of whoop ass and goes ninja. I kinda use the 1 swing, 1 kill mentality, and there are no stray bullets to worry about.
As far as cutting off hands, I have mixed feelings about this. I think it would be good to mark thieves in some way, just not sure if I like the idea of taking the hand. I would be in favor of branding them on the wrist or back of the hand with a permanent mark though.
I did spend some time in Bahrain and while walking around one day, saw a sign on in front of the court house that there would be public amputations that day. They do have a pretty low crime rate.
I used to work in a meat packing house. One day the hock cutter broke, we had to cut the hocks off by hand until it was fixed. That was about 500 hocks/hour. There were 2 of us, so really about 250/hr. (essentially cutting off at the knee joint) I can take your hand off with a butcher knife in about 3 seconds.
Randy