RonFrank
Contributor
The Kraken:Jam,
I'm not pursuing the professional route again!
Just want someting that will give me better than average "vacation" camera abilities.
Depth of field control, detachable strobe for better lighting control, etc.
TTL strobe control.
I'd prefer something that's not enclosed in a separate housing.
Any recommendations would be welcome.
Let's say a top budget range of $1500.
the K
I *did* suggest a DSLR, and for under $1500 with no strobe.
If you want anything other than the internal flash you are NOT going to get TTL control.
There also is nothing that is not in a seperate housing unless you want a Nikonos.
The Canon S80 is a VERY nice camera. I don't like that lack of RAW, but other than that, it's IMO one of the best things out there in a PnS style camera. It is also small, about the size of a pack of cigs or smaller. So it's not bad in a housing.
I would NOT get a DS50 Ikelite. I'd look at the sea&sea digital SL960D for $300 bucks, it comes with an optical sensor, a stepless power adjustment, and works great. My Cuz purchased one last year, and she has been most happy with it. The recycle time is not awesome, but it is actually quite good as one is generally NOT shooting at full power much. She had hers dialed down a good bit for most all shots.
The reason I'm saying to stay clear of the Ikelite is that with a PnS camera, you have to purchase a manual controller, a tray, and arms, and by the time you are done, you have spent $600 for something that is about equal to several $300 flashes that come with everything you need.
The DS50 does NOT have any power adjustment at the flash, it does NOT have a rechargable pack, it does not have a modeling light. What it does have is TTL which is worthless unless you are shooting a DSLR in the Canon or Nikon flavor.
So the S80 runs maybe $450. The housing runs $200. The Sealife runs $300. You have budget to burn HOWEVER if it were me... Id' do the D50 SLR + Fantasea housing, but I'm picky Another housing option is the Ikelite. They are more than twice the cost, and for this type of camera, I kinda don't think its' worth it, but many feel they are superior to the Canon housings. (I shoot an S70 with a Canon housing BTW).