Happened to me on a 109 converted to BA, when I replaced the good old two-parts grey poppet with the newer one-piece S-wing white poppet.Has anyone else ever experienced this? Cheers.
Luckily this happened outside water.
I immediately switched back to the old poppet, replacing the seat (which was retained by a metal pin) and the O-ring.
I learned the lesson: the new S-wing poppet REQUIRES the new lever with larger feet (which is not necessarily curvy - I have a couple of levers with large feet which are flat, not curvy, and they work well with the S-wing poppet).