More news about Playa del Carmen

Please register or login

Welcome to ScubaBoard, the world's largest scuba diving community. Registration is not required to read the forums, but we encourage you to join. Joining has its benefits and enables you to participate in the discussions.

Benefits of registering include

  • Ability to post and comment on topics and discussions.
  • A Free photo gallery to share your dive photos with the world.
  • You can make this box go away

Joining is quick and easy. Log in or Register now!

I'm not putting this out for debate. I am sharing a well written statement prepared by someone who lives in Playa del Carmen Mexico. I did not write this. Copy and share all you like!

I copy this here with the respect and ok of a fellow Playense

I have LIVED here (not just visited) for 15 years (celebrated this week) and feel as safe today as I did when I first moved here. Actually, with the new government in charge and its anti-corruption/crime campaign, I actually feel safer. And, I have a wife and two kids. I have choices. I could easily move to somewhere else in Mexico or back to the States but I know that this area is much safer than the vast majority of places that people visiting here come from. My interaction with organized crime is nil. The amount of times I have been a victim of a crime is nil. My house was broken into when I lived in Cancun some 18 years ago. The experiences of the people I work with and the over 500 students (mostly adult) who study here will mirror mine.
The sensationalism and panic come from outside this area. The people looking in from outside believe a few incidents make for an environment. Gangsters getting shot by other gangsters because they didn't pay their gangster dues would not even make the news in many parts of the world but let it happen here once and it is an international incident covered by a complicit media with vested interests in other travel destinations. Some kids drink too much, too fast and dive into a three foot pool, one on top of the other and the problem is not their bad judgement but the silly notion that a company with the reputation of Iberostar would give its guest tainted alcohol that might lead to someone's death. Parents can't accept their loss and need to blame. Media all over it because, well, it is Mexico and you know how it is. The ferry bomb, who knows. An explosive device with no shrapnel built into it was not meant to maim and kill. It was either a political message or an insurance scam. But, whatever, we are not talking Baltimore or Beirut or Miami here.
People walk the streets, eat in the restaurants, work, play in the park and go about their business like they did 5, 10, 15 and 20 years ago. Sure, things change. What hasn't? We have had a cannibal murderer, a mobbed-up Canadian businessman shot in his AI room, swine flu, Wilma (where we were actually under 10 feet of water according to the news) and gotten through it all. What sucks is that people lose jobs over panic created by people who have no clue.
I ain't in the mood to hear the "20 years and my how things have changed" pitch today. The US government just ****ed our economy over something they don't even have the courtesy to explain.
 
I wanted to say something so bad but had to bite my tongue...:no:

Anyways, we will continue to go to Cozumel and Playa del Carmen because we feel welcome and safe, which is not like some other places we've been to.
 
Today's CBS News story includes the statement "There is information that there could be a violent attack in the next few days, so they're letting people know what they know"

https://www.cbsnews.com/news/playa-del-carmen-mexico-travel-warning-us-real-crime-threat-state-department/

I can see the dilemma, the risk is small and in some ways issuing a travel alert and closing the consulate is playing into the hands of the drug gangs. You are feeding their desire for fear and sensationalism and in doing so, you are helping to perpetuate the vicious cycle of poverty, crime, and violence. Part of me wants to say "The hell with them, I'll do what I want and go where I want, and I won't let them scare me away!"

But on the other hand, the Spring Break/Easter Vacation travel season is about to start and the Yucatan is a very popular vacation destination. If the US Embassy truly has received a credible threat then they would be culpable for not sharing it and advising caution, especially after the other recent attacks and threats.

How would you feel if your child was injured or killed by a narco-terrorism event during a Spring Break vacation and then you found out that the State Department had received warnings but did nothing to alert citizens about a possible danger?

And the suggestions that "Americans aren't being targeted" wouldn't console me if my loved one was killed or injured as a bystander.

I would like to know more information about the threat that has been received so I could judge the risk for myself, but I suppose they worry that giving out the details might incite some crazy copy-cat to attack.

I guess that it is (slightly) positive that the criminals are giving advance warnings and designing bombs that aren't designed to produce a lot of shrapnel because I remember the horror of the Boston marathon bombings; but they are still setting off bombs and I saw the panic and the injured people lying on the pier in the videos after the recent Playa ferry bomb explosion.

I wouldn't want to be anywhere near the area when one of these "safer bombs" goes off. Not in Mexico or anywhere else in the world, including my home town. If there was a threat I would want to know about it so that I could do my best to avoid it. No place in the world is completely safe and there are no guarantees. You always have to be alert and cautious, but avoidance when possible is part of being cautious IMO.

I am reminded that in the early days of World War I, before the US entered the war, the German Embassy published warnings in American newspapers stating that passenger ships may be viewed as legitimate targets. This warning was published in the same newspaper that advertised the sailing of the Lusitania, see below. People ignored the warnings and decided to sail anyway, and a lot of people died horribly. Because of that attack our country was pulled into a terrible war that resulted in many more deaths. So when the bad guys give warnings, I am likely to take them seriously. That's just my opinion.

lusitania.jpg
 
Last edited:
It is bad that this harms the Mexican economy, but people have to keep in mind that the U.S. government has a responsibility to protect U.S, citizens. That is why they issue travel advisories.
That area is probably safe for tourists, but the U.S. government can't just say "it's probably OK to go" They would be neglegent if they didn't issue a warning. They haven't banned U.S. citizens from traveling there, but they have to warn citizens that a dangerous situation is possible.
If it were to turn into an extremely dangerous situation travel there from the U.S. would be banned.

I really hope the situation is controlled quickly so the resorts and employees get back to normal as soon as possible.
 
It is bad that this harms the Mexican economy, but people have to keep in mind that the U.S. government has a responsibility to protect U.S, citizens. That is why they issue travel advisories.
That area is probably safe for tourists, but the U.S. government can't just say "it's probably OK to go" They would be neglegent if they didn't issue a warning. They haven't banned U.S. citizens from traveling there, but they have to warn citizens that a dangerous situation is possible.
If it were to turn into an extremely dangerous situation travel there from the U.S. would be banned.

I really hope the situation is controlled quickly so the resorts and employees get back to normal as soon as possible.

I actually agree to an extent - but I disagree with some of the language they use and the sensational headlines - knowing that that's all people will see - they stop reading and then don't get to this, which is accurate (taken straight from one of the CBS World News reports")

"In January, the State Department issued a travel ban to five Mexican states. Americans visiting other parts of the country -- including Quintana Roo, where Playa del Carmen is located -- are only urged to use "increased caution. But the number of foreign visitors to the resort town jumped more than 18 percent last year, and CBS News travel editor Peter Greenberg says the number of Americans killed in violent crimes in Mexico is very small.

"Every time the United States issues a travel advisory, it's got such a negative connotation, there's an almost immediate knee jerk reaction from people to cancel," says Greenberg, "but in terms of Americans being targeted for violent crime, it doesn't really exist."

Just curious, is there a Travel Advisory issued for travel to Hawaii? There is a REAL Threat there for a Nuclear attack from N. Korea - I'd be far more concerned to travel there than to Mexico - and I have dear dear friends and loved ones in Hawaii. I spent a month there this past year when the threats were ongoing.
 
I actually agree to an extent - but I disagree with some of the language they use and the sensational headlines - knowing that that's all people will see - they stop reading and then don't get to this, which is accurate (taken straight from one of the CBS World News reports")

"In January, the State Department issued a travel ban to five Mexican states. Americans visiting other parts of the country -- including Quintana Roo, where Playa del Carmen is located -- are only urged to use "increased caution. But the number of foreign visitors to the resort town jumped more than 18 percent last year, and CBS News travel editor Peter Greenberg says the number of Americans killed in violent crimes in Mexico is very small.

"Every time the United States issues a travel advisory, it's got such a negative connotation, there's an almost immediate knee jerk reaction from people to cancel," says Greenberg, "but in terms of Americans being targeted for violent crime, it doesn't really exist."

Just curious, is there a Travel Advisory issued for travel to Hawaii? There is a REAL Threat there for a Nuclear attack from N. Korea - I'd be far more concerned to travel there than to Mexico - and I have dear dear friends and loved ones in Hawaii. I spent a month there this past year when the threats were ongoing.


I think sometimes the government is using writers from TMZ. It does sound like a tabloid headline rather than an information release.

FWIW we are trying to save up to travel for vacation. Cozumel is my first choice even with this going on.
 
That’s why I don’t go to the US anymore, all states, cause I’m afraid of being caught up in a school shooting or a club shooting or a concert shooting. :D

Sorry for the sargassum (love that word, I just learned it today).
 
It is very dangerous everywhere in Q. Roo. You should not go because you will die. I will go and take the risk for you.
 
That’s why I don’t go to the US anymore, all states, cause I’m afraid of being caught up in a school shooting or a club shooting or a concert shooting. :D

Sorry for the sargassum.
With that attitude, you can barely dive anywhere
 

Back
Top Bottom