There's no way I'm inclined to give out my personal medical history to a dive shop. The very idea of it . . .no no no, just no.
DIVING OVER 50 YEARS OLD
- Thread starter clarkey
- Start date
Please register or login
Welcome to ScubaBoard, the world's largest scuba diving community. Registration is not required to read the forums, but we encourage you to join. Joining has its benefits and enables you to participate in the discussions.
Benefits of registering include
- Ability to post and comment on topics and discussions.
- A Free photo gallery to share your dive photos with the world.
- You can make this box go away
There's no way I'm inclined to give out my personal medical history to a dive shop. The very idea of it . . .no no no, just no.
There is no need to give a dive shop any of your personal medical info. All they want is a doctor's ok.
I was taking exception to Lorenzoid's idea.
This is an interesting thread and all parties seem to have best interest at heart. That is wonderful.
There are few anomalies like myself. I took up scuba January 2016 at age 53. Recently I've started spearfishing, a sport that tends to make you a solo diver. Also, hunting boats are usually a bit smaller than the cattle boats of South Florida where I dive. Therefore, some of the boats are a bit more work getting into and not crewed with extra hands.
I thinking reviewing medical liability forms and questioning divers that have flags is a good ideas. Also, being very open about the situation regarding medical assistance.
If I make it to 85-100 years and die on the reef, it would certainly be better than dying in the nursing home.
One operator of a shark dive in Jupiter, FL says, "We are all here today because we are not all there." For some that don't dive that is the view of all diving.
The bottom line is, some of us enjoy and revel in not being all there. Being there can pretty darn boring.
My advice is be up front, but don't stop the fun. If some old fat slob becomes chum because his carcas couldn't be pulled back in the boat, oh well. Hopefully he died happy as the Old Man "IN" the Sea.
There are few anomalies like myself. I took up scuba January 2016 at age 53. Recently I've started spearfishing, a sport that tends to make you a solo diver. Also, hunting boats are usually a bit smaller than the cattle boats of South Florida where I dive. Therefore, some of the boats are a bit more work getting into and not crewed with extra hands.
I thinking reviewing medical liability forms and questioning divers that have flags is a good ideas. Also, being very open about the situation regarding medical assistance.
If I make it to 85-100 years and die on the reef, it would certainly be better than dying in the nursing home.
One operator of a shark dive in Jupiter, FL says, "We are all here today because we are not all there." For some that don't dive that is the view of all diving.
The bottom line is, some of us enjoy and revel in not being all there. Being there can pretty darn boring.
My advice is be up front, but don't stop the fun. If some old fat slob becomes chum because his carcas couldn't be pulled back in the boat, oh well. Hopefully he died happy as the Old Man "IN" the Sea.
- Messages
- 5,721
- Reaction score
- 474
That is my take on it, too, Colliam.
Interestingly, "both remote and lacking in a well-developed medical infrastructure" applies to scores and scores of dive locations, some even more so than to Corn Island, including many liveaboards, almost all of Indonesia, Fiji, Marshall Islands, Galapagos, Vanuatu, Myanmar, most of India, New Guinea, Madagascar, Solomon Islands, New Caledonia, Borneo, Lord Howe Island, Cook Islands, almost all of French Polynesia, St. Helena, Reunion Island, most of the Philippines, Kiribati, Easter Island, Tonga, most of the Maldives, Sri Lanka, Palau, Azores, Canary Islands, and the list goes on. I am not aware of any dive ops in these locations that require medical clearance to dive simply on the basis of age.
Cheers,
DocVikingo
Yes, BRT, I have initialed pages of have you this or that. Those lists generally accompany the waiver. The waiver that says I'm assuming all liability (not them).
I guess I'm in the minority here. I would happily dive with this op. I'm in my late 40's and have hit the point in life that knees, hips, shoulders, etc. (not to mention blood pressure)require more than an Advil or 2. This policy tells me that the op is concerned about my health and safety in a remote location. It also tells me that I will hopefully not have to be one of the divers on the boat assisting with CPR, which due to the extreme distance to a trauma center, or even an AED, we are probably just abusing the corpse. Meanwhile the family and/or friends are having one of the worst days of their lives. My vacation is ruined, their lives are forever changed, and the guy is dead...with broken ribs to boot. The physical may or may not have caught the underlying problem, but no physical will definately not catch the problem.
I've seen people in their 20's that probably won't make 30. I dove with a man in his early 30's that easily weighed 400 pounds, puked on the dive boat after every dive, and was on the verge of panic anytime he could not see the Divemaster. There were 4 men and 3 women on the boat and I guarantee there would be no way to get him in the 6 pack boat if we had to. Age is certainly not the only criteria to be concerned about....but it's a damn good place to start. Weight, smoking, drinking, current medications, and other medical history should all be considered in the physical as well.
To the op, I would definately work with DAN to establish a set evacuation protocol. Maybe underwater recompressing would be an option instead of a chamber ride, an AED on the island (preferably on the boat as long as it was safe) and access to a DAN paid helicopter would all be good ideas.
We are all dying, I just don't want to be part of another divers death because they were offended at the requirement of a dive physical. Check your pride, eat your kelp, run your marathon, laugh at me at my funeral, I don't care. The op is trying to avoid a horrible situation, based on a doctors suggestion, that has been supported in this thread as being a reasonable place to start.
Googling corn Island now....
Jay
I've seen people in their 20's that probably won't make 30. I dove with a man in his early 30's that easily weighed 400 pounds, puked on the dive boat after every dive, and was on the verge of panic anytime he could not see the Divemaster. There were 4 men and 3 women on the boat and I guarantee there would be no way to get him in the 6 pack boat if we had to. Age is certainly not the only criteria to be concerned about....but it's a damn good place to start. Weight, smoking, drinking, current medications, and other medical history should all be considered in the physical as well.
To the op, I would definately work with DAN to establish a set evacuation protocol. Maybe underwater recompressing would be an option instead of a chamber ride, an AED on the island (preferably on the boat as long as it was safe) and access to a DAN paid helicopter would all be good ideas.
We are all dying, I just don't want to be part of another divers death because they were offended at the requirement of a dive physical. Check your pride, eat your kelp, run your marathon, laugh at me at my funeral, I don't care. The op is trying to avoid a horrible situation, based on a doctors suggestion, that has been supported in this thread as being a reasonable place to start.
Googling corn Island now....
Jay
Similar threads
