Hey Stuart. I suspect its because with tables, the whole dive was at max depth. I used to get out, check the time and the indicator needle on my depth gauge and use that to work out my repetitive dive times. Since none of my dives were ever square profile, almost always ascending during the dive, I for one was a LOT more conservative then than I am now where I actually end up riding the NDL.
I know a lot of divers that get to NDL-1 then ascend a little up the reef and repeat till gas gone or surfaced. While that is not unsafe as far as Im concerned, it is definitely more aggressive than if you calculated the same dive on regular tables.
That makes perfect sense. Thanks.