Yeah, the final outcome, as I recall, was the the cool-aid club felt that standardization was more important than using the best item for the task. That was an outlook that I simple can not abide, believing as I do in using the best tool for the job. For example, I could not imagine using a bolt snap to secure an umbilical to my harness. This was my introduction to how Doing It Right had as much to do with conformity to a social norm as it did to sensible diving practices. But that's a whole 'nother topic.
After reading through that thread, I came to several conclusions:
* all of your comments were respectful, but curious and challenging
* some of the return commentary was respectful, but much was dismissive and disrespectful
* the disrespect was clearly extended beyond you to any type of diving not-their-own
* conformity and standardization is clearly considered more important than practicality - if the method doesn't fit the situation, why it must be the situation that is wrong!
* if that mindset is indeed prevalent, I suspect that many DIR divers are probably not as capable at adapting and reacting to unexpected situations as they may think - independent thought is discouraged, yet it is the most important ingredient in successful problem solving. What do you do when things go off-script?
* I now understand why I see so many comments about how DIR types don't play well with others
I fully recognize that my own diving experience is quite limited, and that I will likely never attain the experience, knowledge or proficiency levels of some of those I am now criticizing. HOWEVER. I believe that my observations as to attitudes and their impact are not unique to diving but are rather more universal.