Welcome to ScubaBoard, the world's largest scuba diving community. Registration is not required to read the forums, but we encourage you to join. Joining has its benefits and enables you to participate in the discussions.
Benefits of registering include
All is not lost. It turns out an AIR 2 is exactly what I need for this rig. Thanks ScubaBoard
View attachment 99051
View attachment 99052
Right on.
Admittedly, I'm on the outside looking in, without enough scuba experience to have an informed opinion about much of anything, but what I've seen so far leads me to believe that the "DIR" business is akin to a "my way or the highway" mindset, and I want no part of that wherever I see it. It's not hard to spot people who you'd "like to buy them for what they're worth, and sell them for what they think they're worth".
I did not read back threw all the posts in this thread. Skipped around a lot. I found some interesting, even useful info, as well as the usual rants and
I am one who simply does not understand the near hatered some divers seem to have for anyone who dives differently than they choose to. It is all diving, and unless someone's actions creat risk, there is room for all of us.
On our DNY trip to Bonaire a few weeks back we had 27 divers, split roughly 50/50 between traditional BCD and BP/W set ups. Two sidemount divers, one recreational diver with spare air, and I believe a couple ofAir II set ups. As I said, room for all. No one had any issues that they expressed to me as group leader on the trip.
I currently am diving a wing myself, set up in a DIR configuration, and enjoy diving it, but have no trouble sharing dives with divers in entirely different gear combos, or even switching back to dive one of my rec setups.
I do take the time before a dive to make sure I am familiar with other diver's gear, in case there is a problem. I believe that every diver owes that safety concern to every other diver they are going to be U/W with.
Having said that, as I understand the concept; DIR was, and still may be, an evolving gear configuration agreed upon between divers involved in some very serious, potentially high risk diving. The concept was created to ensure that a team of divers in such a high risk environment could respond instantly, and instinctively to a team mate's emergency. Standardized equipment choices, well defined team training and performance standards gives such divers a better chance of returning alive from every dive.
I find a lot of the DIR training very usefull in my regular recreational diving, yet have no issues mixing with divers who are not so trained, as long as they exhibit safe diving practices. Should I continue into more hazardous diving situations in the future, I can see why narrowing my choice of dive partners to someone specifically trained and equiped similar to myself could become a serious safety concern.
I get very tired of seeing one style of diver belittling another style of diver. Usually such rants only lead me to conclude that the poster or ranter, understands very little about the subject.