Sounds like sloppy research by someone at Diver magazine?
For my own interest - what are the really "blue chip" wreck dives in North Carolina? One day I will make it up there.
Not really sloppy, but not understanding what is going on. Yes, the "real" Papoose is probably sitting in 200' water, but the wreck known as the Papoose for many years, the one everyone dives, is in 120' water. The dive ops still call that one the Papoose or Papoose/Hutton, and it is the one that is considered worldclass diving.
As far as what you would consider "blue chip" wreck...
do you mean historic? do you mean good penetration? do you mean lots of growth and fishlife? do you mean sharks?
I think everyone can agree that one of the highlights of the NC coast diving is the u-boats. Morehead City area has the U-352, and up north off Hatteras, there are 2 more u-boats. Though not particularly dramatic visually to most people, they are real WWII history.
Other than those, you might get lots of answers as to which wrecks in area are the best. The Caribsea is popular, as well as the Spar and Schurz and Proteus and Atlas and Cassimir and.....
Jlyle, here on SB, wrote a nice trip report here:
http://diver.net/bbs/posts002/72000.shtml
robin