I like paper. I started with the PADI logbook I got with my OW course, then when that was full I ordered some "custom" logbook pages from divelogs.com. (They're not really customizable; they just have a lot of options and really user-friendly decision tree software that leads you to one result instead of having to scroll through thousands.)
I note total dive time rather than bottom time, and now that I have a computer that tells me the water temperature at the surface and at depth I note both, along with air temp/ weather, exposure protection, and how warm I was. I calculate and record RMV and try to make note of anything that might have influenced it; since my computer now tells me my SAC rate in real time, I also sometimes note high and low points to get a better picture of what the whole-dive average represents. I've learned that beach diving means a really high SAC rate at the start, probably from the exertion of walking from my car to the water in full gear (and often a long surface swim.) I note the critters I saw and my buddies, and anything new I learned or things I struggled with. I don't bother with signatures or stamps anymore; I write a lot and want as much space as I can get. Sometimes I spill over onto a second page.
I haven't been very motivated to upload my dive profiles from my computer. I feel like I should do that too, but it feels like a chore whereas writing by hand is somehow fun. I'm 36 and have had a personal computer in the home since age 7 and a cell phone since age 18, for what that's worth.