I learned to dive in 1978 not only before dive computers, but before personal computers!
For the first few years I logged my dives in the logs I got as part of my course.
From late 1980 until 1998 I was using desk diaries to keep track of my dives. I wasn't diving all that often (maybe 5-20 times a year) and most of my dives were local. Somehow when we moved house in 1998 I lost the diaries (but not the original log books) so I have little information about 18 years of dives other than what I can piece together from the slides I took on some of the dives.
From 1998 I vowed that wouldn't happen again so I started keeping my logs electronically. There wasn't any 3rd party dive log software at the time so I created my own using Lotus Notes. I'm still using my custom dive log software some 22 years later.
My custom dive log has evolved somewhat in the 22 years (and is still evolving as I add more features). I also use OEM and 3rd party software to ease the import of data from my dive computers. For example, I use MacDive to get the data from my Garmin Descent Mk1 (although I'm getting extremely frustrated with the bugs that I have reported that haven't been fixed and may switch to using Subsurface. I use Shearwater Desktop to get the data from my Perdix and very old Windows based software to get the data from my Citizen Hyper Aqualand. I have automated the logging as much as possible to make it easier, quicker and more accurate.
My logs are quite detailed and not only include the usual data such as weights, exposure suit, tank sizes, starting and ending pressures, but I also (when I have time) write up a detailed account of the dive. I find the detailed account helps me remember the dive better including what I saw (which is usually backed up with photographs) but also what I didn't see. I dive the same sites often and so I track a lot of animals.
Here's an example of the level of detail in my logs:
Dive at The Steps, Kurnell, NSW on Sunday 28 June 2020 - ATJ's Diving Site
I have also automated the publishing of my logs to my website. It's not that I think anyone is particularly interested but it is an easy way for me to look at my logs when I'm out and about.
Like Stuart, I find keeping detailed logs helps me answer a bunch of questions, like temperature, weights, and especially SAC/RMV which I analyse after the dive to understand why it might have been higher than usual (cold, current, surge, etc.)