Tina (et.al.),
Up to this point, I have tried to be middle of the road .... but my two cents;
I read this thread with amazement. I grew up diving on the East Coast. I have dove most of the lakes in Colorado (spent 8 years there). I have seen hundreds, maybe thousands of divers go into the Ocean off the coast of Mass./Rhode Island / Long Island and mountain lakes with visibility comparable to or lower than Lake Pleasant (and other conditions much worse). Yes that includes beginner divers too.
Lake Pleasant has its moments and as Steve has eluded, I do a fair amount of beginner and advanced training in Lake Pleasant (about 200 training dives per year). To sit here and discuss Lake Pleasant as an unsafe diving environment is absurd. Yes, that is my opinion and you are entitled to your own. But remember, as instructors, our opinions carry a lot of weight. So when you sit here and pontificate or paint pictures of strings of panic in the lake (from people snorkeling

), you are just influencing people out of the local waters. That is a huge dis-service to the local dive community and industry. Maybe Lake Pleasant is not the greatest, but it isn't that bad.
FYI - Lake Pleasant Conditions:
5 to 15 feet of visibility.
Temp: Low 70s
Plenty of gravel dive sites -- like Scorpion Bay. Stay on the West side (wind blows West to East). Most of the silt ends up on the East Side. Want to stay off the bottom, dive the dam. Looking for a good place to practice skills, try Desert Tortoise Road. During the winter time, I have seen Lake Pleasant visibility get upwards of 30-40 feet. Yes, you heard me. 30+ feet.
As for experience, there is plenty to see. Big, and I mean big, catfish and karp. Some great underwater landscape including some small walls that are just fun to cruise around. At night, you can dive for crawdads. Wanna treasure hunt, plenty of fishing lores and sunglasses.
I set expectations right. This is not Bonaire or Cozumel. It is Lake Pleasant! It is one of the best training grounds I know of - beginner or advanced. If you can dive Lake Pleasant; you can just about dive anywhere.
As for shops that choose not to train in the lakes. Thank you very much. I am more than happy to train whatever students you don't want too. For those potential divers who are looking at various training options, I think this thread is proof that you need to do your due diligence and not latch on to the first piece of hooey someone throws your way.
In the spirit of our favorite
Dive a holic: If you are considering beginner or advanced dive training, shoot me a PM. I'll give you some honest opinions, no sales rhetoric, great value and should you choose me (and the shop I am affiliated with) a safe and enjoyable training experience.
Have a great day diving.
jcf
PS - Many Many Many lake dives and never been entangled in fishing line. Yes, I do still dive with a cutting device or two -- just in case.
///