Welcome to SB. Similar story, just resumed diving after 26 years on the surface. Reactivated PADI AOW and obtained Nitrox cert.
Given your location, it seems you will be a travel diver. Me too. No more hoods, gloves or thick wetsuits.
My last BC was an Aqualung Calypso, pretty bare bones but good for travel. So I was biased to get another jacket.
After much research, I bought a SP Level and dove it in Maui off the beach. Very nice for that application (walking around wearing a tank and integrated weights). It’s a good blend of “lightweight” and “fully featured.” Get the 2022 version with trim pockets mounted high on the rear. Buoyancy is 22 to 38 pounds, depending on size. Weight is up to 6.6 pounds. Weight integration is much better than a weight belt. The Level is not as “jackety” as the Classic; it is comfortable. Many shops use the Level as their go-to for rentals, so they must be tough as well.
Now: the diving world has changed a lot. At least on SB, many experienced divers have come to prefer back-inflate BCs, or at the tech-oriented end, backplate/wing setups. The simplest BP/Ws run around $400 US, but you can spend plenty more.
For my next trip to Cozumel and for boat diving in general, I bought this:
We understand what the active diver needs from a single tank rig. Simple, streamlined, balanced, and easy to travel. We built the Paragon single tank package to offer a modular and customizable BCD to best suit single tank diving needs. At the heart of the Paragon Single Tank Package is the...
sub-gravity.com
And in case you are intrigued by the BP/W concept, here is the rabbit hole that led me to Subgravity:
Hello friends. I've recently returned to diving after a 26 year surface interval. I geared up for shore diving in Maui and was pleased with the 2022 Scubapro Level BC; it is comfortable for walking around with tank and integrated weights. It's basically a better version of what I learned on. I...
scubaboard.com