ALL:
Thanks bunches for your advice. VERY helpful. Based on your input, our own research and scheduling dictates, here is what we have decided to do (subject to change, based on developments):
a). March 4th: Get ferry from Coz to PDC soon enough that we can get a car rented before the rental places close (which seems to be about 4PM).
b). March 4th: Drive rental car from PDC to Cancun and stay the night at a hotel (wife will pick out - she wants to be "downtown"). Can spend evening walking around and doing whatever.
c). March 5th: Next day, drive to C.I. and do whatever there is to do, drive back to Cancun and spend the night in the same hotel.
d). March 6th: Next day, have a leisurely morning - drop rental car off at noon or so, catch 3pm(ish) flight home.
This puts us in control of our own destiny, at the risk of potential rental car issues. It also means we don't have to drive all the way back from C.I. to PDC, just to go to sleep and then go to the Cancun airport. It also gives the dive gear a chance to dry out, sitting in the Cancun hotel room while we're in C.I.
Definitely want to avoid driving in dark if possible. What time is sun up/down the first week of March down there? Considered staying in C.I., but hotels there seem to be expensive, plus it means dive gear is sitting in the car all day since we would get to C.I. too early to check in, PLUS it means we would drive back from C.I. to Cancun the morning of our flight home - which doesn't strike me as a very good idea.
So anyway - we'll be in PDC just long enough to get a rental car and get out of town. We have two nights in Cancun, and a day driving to C.I. and back. It's possible we might take some kind of bulk transport from PDC to Cancun, in the event we're unable to rent a car there for one reason or another (for example, by the time we get there, everything is closed, or it's going to be dark, or whatever). That means we'd have to rent a car in Cancun the morning of our drive to CI, which of course, is something I'd like to avoid.
For an excursion to Chitzen Itza, I suggest renting a car and driving. It'll give you the freedom to pace the trip to suit your own taste, and do some side trips. Two hints, one pick up your car the night before, so you can get an early start and get there before high noon. Second, where you pay to enter Chitzen Itza try to find other independents and share the cost of a local guide. The guides are very knowledgeable and well worth the cost.
Thanks
driving is definitely cheaper, plus you aren't rushed like the tour groups. Get the map/guide here: Can-Do Travel Guides. Mayan Adventure map gives everything you need to know, along with restaurants, side excursions, road tolls, etc.
Thanks
Yes, you want full & total insurance, but it's pretty cheap with some providers. I got hot over the delivery service in PDC but I'm a hothead anyway. Try Cancun Car Rental, Rent a car in Cancun, Playa del Carmen Easy Way Car Rental
I'm getting conflicting advice. Seems to be a 50/50 split between depend on the credit card coverage, or buy the mexican policy.
Be careful again about gas. Being American, I presumed all the stations were open Sunday mornings. Ha! Top it off the night before you need it - but watch out for the helpful locals who want to do it for you - be sure the meter is zeroed out. Most locals are pretty nice folks, but one crook can spoil your day.
Thanks
May I suggest a safe place would be a good choice. The peninsula is not like Cozumel, and you want to be prudent about some choices at either.
Ah, OK.
You plan to spend a lot of time at the pool?
If it has one, probably, yeah. I can't stand the heat (hey, I'm from Alaska, OK?). Seems like a pool would be the coolest place to hide out from it.
It costs as much to live a first world life style in Mexico as it does in the States.
Well, that sucks. But it also varies dramatically. I've paid everything from $500/night to $40/night in the U.S. It really depends on where you are. But, for example, in Egypt, it is dirt cheap to stay in a very nice place (that would cost hundreds in America). I was hoping the same would be true in Mexico, but I guess not.
Since you sound as cheap as I am, if you don't order the maps you are penny wise and pound foolish. We have been buying them for the past 8 years and always get the latest edition before we plan a trip. Laura and Perry put out a great product that is worth its weight in gold.
Well, I guess I should clarify. Perhaps it is not so much that I am cheap, as much as it is that I don't value certain things as highly as others - while I overvalue other things, according to most people. For example - although I could have easily gone out and bought a brand new vehicle - I was driving a 14 year old beater of a truck with 200,000+ miles on it - but had a $1000 pool cue. Neither one bothered me very much at all, but other people didn't understand it. When it comes to hotels - I just see them as a place to put my stuff and sleep. I don't put much value on niceties. I'd happily sleep in a storage unit for $10/night, as long as it were clean, air conditioned and secure. I don't need much for a hotel. As for map - I see a lot of value in good information, so it's something I'll pay for
Three Pemex stations you want to avoid are at the intersection of 307 and Constituyentes in PDC, the first station on 307 after leaving the airport in Cancun and Puerto Morelos. Never give your keys to the attendant. Get out of the car, remove the gas cap yourself and watch every step and ask for a specific amount of gas. BTW, be sure to tip the person filling your car.
Thanks
Another word of caution about driving from PDC to Chichen Itza. You really have to pay close attention to the signs, other drivers, potholes and ESPECIALLY the speed bumps. We just about launched ourselves into space the last time on one we didn't see til last minute. Most are marked so just pay closer attention that we did.
Thanks
From either Playa or Cancun, it's faster and safer to use the toll road (Cuota) -- it's expensive and less scenic than the free road but high-speed divided highway to Piste -- the town closest to the ruins. There's a toll booth at the Q.Roo/Yucatan state line. To get there from Playa, go north on 307 toward the airport and you'll see the entrance before you enter Cancun.
Thanks
2.) drive yourself...great option to save money. it will take a little time off the drive simply because you are controlling when you stop. The highway to C.I. from Cancun is a toll-way, very nice road, or at least was 5 years ago or so. There are restaurants, snack shops and souvenir shops at the site and you can hire a private tour guide for the day for about $25 plus tip. Or just study up a little before you go and give yourself the tour. A little tip, itÃÔ easy to slip into the crowd of a tour and listen to their tour guide as you walk around the site yourself.
Thanks
And thanks to all for your feedback too
Cheers!
nd