Welcome to ScubaBoard, the world's largest scuba diving community. Registration is not required to read the forums, but we encourage you to join. Joining has its benefits and enables you to participate in the discussions.
Benefits of registering include
I'd prefer a nice divers automatic watch (assuming thats his style) because it has far far more longevity than a dive computer (which.. is much like a smartphone or laptop - constantly upgrading technology).
Care to tell us why that watch is not suitable? It's rated to 1650 feet.
Really?
I bought a Suunto Cobra 11 years ago. I still have it although I don't use it much any more, for reasons unrelated to its ability. It still works fine, and in fact it has more features than I need. You can still buy a brand new Suunto Cobra today with the same technology at about the same price I paid for it 11 years ago.
The fact that new computers come out with new features does not mean you need to buy them. You really only need a few features in a computer, and once you have them, you can ignore the newest bells and whistles.
EDIT: I have a couple of dive watches I use in the pool while working with students. I never even wear them on actual dives.
The problem I have with my dive watch is that I'm scared to scratch it up or lose it. My wife gave me a Tag Heuer Super Professional for a wedding gift. It is rated to 1000M and is made for diving but the thought of losing a 3K watch freaks me out. I know their are nice watched for a lot less but I'm just saying....dive computer is rugged and made for diving abuse. Many dive watches seem like they may not take abuse as well as a computer.