My winter water temps range from 32-38 degrees F. My summer temps range from 37-42 degrees F. I run the same gloves year round. I also use the fourth E g1 liners. I have been pleased with them.In the summer months I use thinner gloves, the G17K style black&white. This gives me more dexterity and I can feel far more through them.
My winter gloves are thicker but I loose dexterity and can’t feel a thing; like wearing boxing gloves (sort of). This makes simple bolt snap manipulation a right challenge, especially any smaller clips. The hardest thing is trying to sort out a tangle or even cross-clipped boltsnaps when you can’t see them.
Winter gloves are very resilient to cuts/holes.
Summer gloves are far more susceptible to tiny holes or tearing. Particularly if heaving a sidemount bungee which catches the fingertip. I’ve had full glove floods, leaks and a total rip. Whenever that happens it’s imperative to get the equalisation string out of the cuff seal. I use a larger knot which can be pulled through from the outside of the glove. At the worst case I would take the glove off underwater and sort out the seal.
BTW I use Fourth Element Glove Liners which are thin neoprene gloves. These are warm when wet but are thin enough to feel through. In winter I’ll add some wrist warmers.
G1 Glove Liner - Fourth Element
For use under drygloves or wet mitts. 1.5mm hydrofoam provides the confidence that in case of dryglove failure they will retain and provide thermal protection.fourthelement.com
Since my diving is done in cold water, I don't have small boltsnaps on anything except my travel specific gear.
