Ben_ca:
Greetings from down south (Monterey) I hope you don't mind if I intrude but I'm thinking of putting one of these on and I could use some ideas...
From the newer divers:
Did the big buddy dives help you?
What worked... what would you like to see in the future.
Ben,
I'd strongly encourage you to do this down in Monterey. As a newer diver, these dives have helped me a lot (actually, I only made the first one-damn work gets in the way sometimes).
What worked: Both Bob and Lynne made it a low pressure, welcoming environment. One of the things that may be intimidating to newer divers is diving with people with a lot more experience. With that being said, it was a good environment to receive advice, after all, these were mentor dives, and that advice was given in a low-key manner. New divers are looking for chances to dive with others, so it should be fairly easy to dredge a crew up.
For me, why I found them valuable is (1) I was further exposed to a different style of diving (in a no pressure manner); (2) I met a great dive buddy (Lynne); and (3) I learned a lot about where my diving could go (still working on getting there).
What I'd want to see in the future is quite simple. Keep it low-key (this is one of Bob's real strengths as a teacher, he gets you out there, having fun, and the learning happens along the way). Also, keep it welcoming to all types and skill levels, to the credit of the mentors, I've never seen or heard of an instance where any frustration was expressed in regards to the newer divers. That is one of the reasons why these dives work.
One of these days, I want to get down to Monterey. I grew up in Los Altos, lived in Santa Cruz for 4 years, but grew up surfing and didn't dive at the time . . .