Hmm, also being an 8.5 foot I'm a tad undecided on the size of booties to order... I'm spending March in Florida so while there I'll order a set of Eddies and 3mil booties (all my diving is warm water Caribbean). Not sure if I should go for a size 8 boot or a 9 and wear the neoprene sock I currently use in my size 9 full foot fins. I also have short feet, but the arch is high so I can sometimes get away with a size 9 (with lots of toe space).
How loose is the 9 on you?
Decisions decisions!
Not bad at all with the thick boots... as they have laces.
The thin boots with just the zipper are large. I don't wear them anymore, and they'll be hitting craigs or eBay soon.
- K