look, I've had more than one major manufacturers CEO (President) - not some flunky sales rep (those are the ones who lie) tell me that thier competitors are shipping pallets of goods to the online sellers.
I have no problem with this if MAP pricing is done away with. It seems as though the goal is to put the dive shops out of business. Whenever I try to advertise a competitive price... I get a call from the sales rep telling me I'm in violation of the MAP policy and I'm threatended with having my dealership yanked.
You make a good point, one which LP fans often make themselves. The source of the "problem" is the manufacturers, not the evil online retailer. Manufacturers like to play both sides of the fence, publicly supporting the LDS and encouraging customers to buy there while privately selling to LP where they are free of warranty obligations.
The issue is that most LDS owners are afraid to finger the manufacturer so throw all the blame at LP, having to make allegations of counterfeit gear or inferior gear or buying out failed dealers. They can't say it's the same current gear as in their shop because that would finger the manufacturer and small LDS owners are afraid of having their dealerships pulled. But when divers eventually find out the truth, they feel like the LDS owner lied to them and they are alienated against the LDS owner not the manufacturer.
BTW, you know that MAP doesn't apply to closeouts and since LP buys in huge quantities they are going to have closeouts with every model change. There's nothing wrong with closeouts, often the "new model" is no better than the older one just different so the manufacturer can cash in on those percentage of divers who always have to have the latest thing. I doubt it takes LP very long to blow out a line.