Just so you know, Bonaire is still essentially closed to U.S. residents. Some NE state residents (including your NY) can get in through Curaçao, but only after a negative PCR COVID test within 72 hours before arriving in Curaçao.
So a January trip doesn't seem feasible without some travel gymnastics.
Unless I've missed a recent reopening...
(I'm still worried about my April scheduled trip to Divi Flamingo in Bonaire)
Bonaire has actually reopened to US visitors. The hard part has been getting there. I just booked yesterday for December 5-12. Super cheap airfare too!!