I cannot speak to the conditions at SCC, now or earlier, because I have never stayed there, but the place certainly has its fans who post on here.Me, the instructors at my shop and our customers liked it alot when it was Galapago Inn. Myself and another dive shop owner/instructor did a last minute trip for a week in January 2024 and another week at Chinchorro Reef at the Mexico / Belize border. We went to spread another friend's ashes as his last wishes. We had been going to other hotels and beach homes for the last 15+ years and diving with 'Dive with Martin', 'Aldora Divers' and Costa Maya Charters when Rollie was still open. SCC was awful in January of 2024. The service and food was aweful and limited.in the afternoon. We were crammed on boats like cattle and we couldn't even pay to do an extra 2 afternoon dives. Only shore dives were available to us. There were 50+ divers from the Villages in Central Florida for part of our time there and they all had issues with their rooms, clean rooms but in disrepair. The food servers and bartenders were horrible. Their dining area was no longer open after lunch. The person working the bar was always on his phone and did not want to be bothered serving us beer. In hindsight, they must have known there were problems. The older dive shop guys were good and I rememebered from long ago. The rest were rude or lazy. Boat boys were each expecting tips after they ignored us every day. We tipped the staff we liked well but the place was in great need of repair. I think it is best they're closing. Most of Cozumel shuts down when the last cruise ship leaves port.
Cozumel used to be a great place. I used to live at Punta Sur, Devils Throat and Maricaibo to the south and the great Barracuda Drift dive to the north, which has not been dove by tourists since the late 80s or early 90s. They cater to newbies now I believe. For those that knew the Cozumel of the 80s and 90s. Back in the day of La Ceiba, Scuba Hut, Carlos and Charlies, etc... save your time and pick somewhere else.
if you must go the best restaraunt that is still open and thriving is La Choza by far.
What do you mean by "...the great Barracuda Drift dive to the north, which has not been dove by tourists since the late 80s or early 90s."? Dive ops don't go there as often as they do the southern reefs, but visitors to the island do dive Barracuda.
I also don't know what you mean by "Most of Cozumel shuts down when the last cruise ship leaves port." That certainly is not the case. It's not like Cancun (thank goodness) but the bars and restaurants are open long after the cruseros have left.
And while La Choza is indeed excellent, there are plenty of other great restaurants on the island, both new and old.