OK so this is my opinion and I am sure others will different. For me getting a rebreather was to be able to do deep wreck diving and help on the cost of amount of HE needed do do these trips (4-5 sets of doubles and 10 deco bottles for a typical overnight trip) as well as quicker turn around time. It also give me the additional benefit if a offshore trip gets blown out or changed to a shallower wreck I am not wasting expensive mixes to do the dives. I believe a diver should be trained and capable of planning and conducting tec dives to at least 150' before looking in to a rebreather. When the rebreather fails you back to OC diving and should be comfortable diving OC at depth, and making gas switches correctly for your deco.
Even the simpliest rebreathers are not as simple as grabbing a BC, Reg, tank and jumping in the water doing a dive. I really dont see the need for a recreation rebreather except the agenices are missing out on money by not having a CCR program. Unless you are conducting very long shallow dives like 2-3 hours at 60' I would sick to OC.
As for wildlife coming closer I have had animals come up to me on OC and CCR as so I can touch them, so I think its more of a matter of me being slow and comfortable in the water then a function of no bubbles. So I think you should think long and hard about if a CCR is really needed and if so do you have the dive experience to do proper gas planning and making switches to bailout gas?
If you say yes I need/want a CCR then here are some questions to consider:
Rec or Tec?
Backmounted, Over the shoulder or top of shoulder Countter Lungs?
Does it need to be CE approved?
Do you want a manual, manual assisted or electronic CCR?
Are there other CCR divers in your area with similar units to help mentor you?
Can you get parts/spares for the particular unit?
I prefer backmounted counter lungs and manual assisted ccr's. I own a dive a Kiss Classic which is a simple unit, and reliable. I have had the unit in caves for up to 4 hrs and on wrecks off the NE coast of the USA in 300'+ of water. I also took revo course since some friends bought them to be familiar with the unit and I thought it was a solid unit but def with more features then my Kiss. I think for what you are looking for a hammerhead is over kill. Also I like the manual assisted units because you are more in touch with whats going on with a unit then having the electronics do it for you.
---------- Post added February 1st, 2014 at 08:48 PM ----------
Three that come to mind....
- Peace and quiet in the water
- Constant PPO2 set point increasing NDL time
- Closer interactions with marine life
OK it is quite unless other divers are OC
Are you running out of BT with your tanks? not just a single tank I mean doubles?
I have had close encounters on both I think its more of a matter of how you move in water and breath then OC vs CC
Anyway this is getting away from OPs topic.