@Thunder Struck you are missing several other groups of divers who would potentially benefit. It’s not one or the other from your breakdown.
My DM has one and loves it. This was during last shore dives in Ft Lauderdale a few weeks ago. So go figure.
I think we should stop analyzing what we don’t know and let the market speak for itself.
I don't want to see it fail, I'd like to see it succeed. However, it's the subscription cost of the app that I have a hard time swallowing. It has a nice interface and appears fairly easy to use based on what I've been seeing at their site:
Oceanic Plus - Oceanic Worldwide. While I don't have any desire to purchase an Apple watch, let alone the Ultra, (I have a Garmin athletic watch at work and for running but otherwise I'm wearing a Citizen automatic), people are welcome to spend their deneros as they see fit.
My Suunto Spyder was perfectly readable when I was 20 years younger, but I think I've rounded the corner in my ability to read those smaller digital watch displays. I have a Deep6 Excursion that is about at the limit of my ability although I prefer the gauge reader masks at this point. My Spyder, not so much without gauge readers given the relatively thin and low contrast LCD style characters.
As for the battery life, it's something that the watch's owner will likely have accustomed themself to. Short of being in some remote wilderness area where there is no power or on a long backpacking excursion, when they sleep they can simply place it on the charger. I do this routine with my hearing aids each night and don't find it cumbersome. Sucks to have to bring one more charging device but how much more is it truly?
What I would like to see is Apple allow other people to develop apps for it utilizing the pressure sensor and not just limiting the use of it to Oceanic.
And if folks look at their fancy new $800 watch and have never thought about scuba diving before, but now this generates some interest in diving to where they get out and at least take a DSD class, I'd call it a win.