As for tables, I think some people think their PDC is working out the table for them rather than calculating the algorithm that was used to create the table. That's why they seem to think the table is required to teach decompression theory. The table is not the algorithm, but a manual dive computer.
I agree. The tables are just an illustration of the theory. If you aren't going to be using the tables, then focus on the theory. I wouldn't teach the tables at all, because they aren't exactly intuitive once you move beyond the first dive and half-assing the training is potentially dangerous. The best use I can see for them for OW is for giving examples of how NDL decreases with depth and the effect of longer SIs on repetitive dive.
When I took OW in 2001, we spent probably 6x as much classroom time on the tables as we did on the theory even though most divers were already using computers. My son just got certified and I noticed the course has almost entirely dumped the table portion. I also noticed they used the time savings to shorten the course rather than expand the theory section or to work through how to use a computer.
Back to the original question. I don't see the point in buying expensive computers for the non-technical diving I do. I bought my first set of dive gear in 2003 or 4 as a package deal and it came with a basic Aeris computer in a console. In 2008, I got nitrox certified and switched to the cheapest Nitrox computer at the time, an Oceanic VEO 100 NX ($225 from Scubatoys) on a wrist mount which I used until the pressure sensor died on (luckily) my last dive on a trip to Coz in Dec 2019. I am currently using a Deep6 Excursion ($200 pre-release price).
Here's my then 11-year-old Veo in the Similans: