I'm needing to have these serviced and I'm trying to determine their value
If you wanna “max out” your value, and as you say they were never in water:
The 1st stage would probably be in the clear and
might not need any service — you’ll have to check (or more of ask someone who knows what they’re doing to do that) IP and confirming it’s in spec
But Orings do degrade with storage/not moving/varying weather and storage conditions… so might be a good idea to have it all changed anyways
The 2nd stages:
If they were stored with the seat saver on (the purge button pushed in and twisted) then the same applies, and maybe some min tuning is needed
If not, they will (if not also orings like above) need LP seats to be changed — unlike HP seats
If you’re/know a (regulator) DIY person, the whole thing (service) can go as low as 10 bucks (just after market LP seats for 2nd stages)
And depending on failures of other components (and/or things being out of spec).. well service kit prices + labor
Now that all of that is out of the way, their SP equivalence means nothing actually since the Halcyon branding (for some reason that escapes me — but has to do with status amd GUE) makes them go for more than their SP counterparts (that are no longer available on the “new” market”)
For reference, I got a hold of 3x1st stages and 3x2nd stages (of that generation/cosmetic style) at almost new state at 900eur, and serviced them myself (one 1st stage needed a full service due to IP creep, all 2nds just got LP seats) for 45 (30 for a 1st service kit, 15 for new seconds seats) — technically the 1st needed a new piston (that I restored) that would have cost 70eur, no labor obviously
Another FYI: brand new (with new (ugly imo) cosmetics— same exact internals) kit , in box, like this from big H runs at ~950eur now, so making it worth it for the buyers as well is a factor
YMMV, wildly