You guys understand that we are talking about a gauge that is maybe 10oz.. A pound if you get the biggest one you can find... It's adding maybe 3" to the length of the SPG... This sounds like talking about getting a hose that's 1" shorter so you're more streamline and you'll have a great SAC rate...
And the diver has a camera that is 15lbs and 6 lights sticking out...
Jim..
My interest is in how many redundancies is plenty, and would an analog depth gauge ever save my repetitive dive plan for the day. Considering two computers between my wife and I, I'm not hearing a convincing argument that an additional gauge would save anything. Trying to apply a modern K.I.S.S. methodology, i.e. carry the stuff that helps; don't carry the stuff that is of nominal value.