Rob9876
Contributor
I think that's 99% true, with perhaps the rare exception being that you can do a great night shore dive from Tikila that can equal or exceed a boat night dive on Paradise reef (where the majority of boat night dives take place). I hear good things about night dives from SCC also.Be advised that this is a relative assessment; there is no shore diving from Cozumel that compares favorably with the diving there from boats by any standard of comparison. No one goes to Cozumel for the shore diving.
And yes, everything is relative -- I'd take a daytime shore dive at Tikila over a shore dive at the Panama City Beach jetties any time, and probably most other FL panhandle shore dives. Tikila shore dives can't come close to compare to boat dives on Columbia, Palancar, and most other Cozumel reefs, but they can be a fun and cheaper addition to a trip.