I had the same issue booking my upcoming trip in May. It took me 3 attempts to get a response before finally getting one. In that time frame my airfare for 2 went up by $150 per person.
If I would have known that would happen I would have bit the bullet and paid for the phone call. I was also disappointed to hear that the inclusive "dive day lunches" have disappeared since we were last there 3 months ago. Not sure about the 1 included dinner, but I'm guessing it's gone too. Someone mentioned booking air first, I've always booked far enough out to do it the opposite way. I like too book hotel first, especially in this instance. I love the BA!! Even with this incident, It's still a top notch resort that Eva runs
Can't wait for May!!!!