Can we go to Coz yet?

Please register or login

Welcome to ScubaBoard, the world's largest scuba diving community. Registration is not required to read the forums, but we encourage you to join. Joining has its benefits and enables you to participate in the discussions.

Benefits of registering include

  • Ability to post and comment on topics and discussions.
  • A Free photo gallery to share your dive photos with the world.
  • You can make this box go away

Joining is quick and easy. Log in or Register now!

Medical experts have found that having it once does not make you immune or even safe to others. If you have an MD, then give us your educated opinion.

Medical experts have found no such thing. The evidence suggests - and Dr. Fauci agrees - that there appears to be some short-term immunity. What is not known is how long it lasts.

“With this spike protein that’s being presented in the way that we do it with primes and in some cases boosts, we’re going to assume that there’s a degree of protection, but we have to assume that it’s going to be finite,” he added during a Q&A discussion with Dr. Francis Collins, director of the National Institutes of Health.

Fauci, the director of the National Institutes of Allergy and Infectious Diseases, added that reports of recovered Covid-19 patients being reinfected with the virus are probably inaccurate. He said it’s more likely that the test used to detect Covid-19 probably picked up fragments of the virus still in the recovered patient’s body, but they probably hadn’t been reinfected.

“There are no documented cases where people got better and actually got sick again in the sense of virus replicating,” he said. “I wouldn’t be surprised if there’s a rare case of an individual who went into remission and relapsed. ... But Francis, I can say with confidence, that it is very unlikely if it’s a common phenomenon.”

Dr. Fauci says coronavirus immunity may be 'finite,' duration remains uncertain
 
Medical experts have found that having it once does not make you immune or even safe to others. If you have an MD, then give us your educated opinion.
I have one of those.
The educated opinion - is that we do not know for sure whether antibodies is the sole source of immunity against COVID-19 and how long they last. For that reason, even if effective vaccine is developed, we are not sure how long the immunity will last. Furthermore, drawing parallels from SARS, people who did not have a severe infection may loose their antibodies sooner.
Here is a good article in the nature magazine for reference: https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-020-01989-z

Btw, this article also has a reference that studies how our genetic make-up can modify the degree of how ill we get if we contract COVID-19.
In summary, there is no reliable long term data, so most of the evidence in regard to long-term immunity we have is Level V (the weakest level - or what is called “expert opinion”)
 
Medical experts have found no such thing. The evidence suggests - and Dr. Fauci agrees - that there appears to be some short-term immunity. What is not known is how long it lasts.

“With this spike protein that’s being presented in the way that we do it with primes and in some cases boosts, we’re going to assume that there’s a degree of protection, but we have to assume that it’s going to be finite,” he added during a Q&A discussion with Dr. Francis Collins, director of the National Institutes of Health.

Fauci, the director of the National Institutes of Allergy and Infectious Diseases, added that reports of recovered Covid-19 patients being reinfected with the virus are probably inaccurate. He said it’s more likely that the test used to detect Covid-19 probably picked up fragments of the virus still in the recovered patient’s body, but they probably hadn’t been reinfected.

“There are no documented cases where people got better and actually got sick again in the sense of virus replicating,” he said. “I wouldn’t be surprised if there’s a rare case of an individual who went into remission and relapsed. ... But Francis, I can say with confidence, that it is very unlikely if it’s a common phenomenon.”

Dr. Fauci says coronavirus immunity may be 'finite,' duration remains uncertain
Dr Fauci is continuing to provide us with the weakest level of evidence (expert opinion). He has no evidence to support his opinion, that one would develop life-long immunity after contracting COVID-19.
 
Dr Fauci is continuing to provide us with the weakest level of evidence (expert opinion). He has no evidence to support his opinion, that one would develop life-long immunity after contracting COVID-19.

Did you read what Fauci said? He specifically states..."have to assume that it's going to be finite" when talking of immunity.
 
Dr Fauci is continuing to provide us with the weakest level of evidence (expert opinion). He has no evidence to support his opinion, that one would develop life-long immunity after contracting COVID-19.

It's not his opinion that one would develop "life-long" immunity. He said he expected it to be "finite". No one has claimed life-long immunity. Straw man.
 
Medical experts have found that having it once does not make you immune or even safe to others. If you have an MD, then give us your educated opinion.
Cites?
 
It's not his opinion that one would develop "life-long" immunity. He said he expected it to be "finite". No one has claimed life-long immunity. Straw man.
The point is he does not know one way or the other. He provides you with his expert opinion which is his best guess. The COVID immunity could be like a chicken pox, which is life long for a lot of people, or could be 2 months long. There is no reliable data. I do not rely on expert opinions but prefer to review a data when it is available.
 
Did you read what Fauci said? He specifically states..."have to assume that it's going to be finite" when talking of immunity.
“Have to assume” is the key word in this statement. There is an adage about that.
 

Insufficient data. Nothing published to support conferred immunity. Onus is on claimant to prove immunity. Not the other way around.
 
The point is he does not know one way or the other. He provides you with his expert opinion which is his best guess. The COVID immunity could be like a chicken pox, which is life long for a lot of people, or could be 2 months long. There is no reliable data. I do not rely on expert opinions but prefer to review a data when it is available.

No, the point is that neither he nor anyone else was talking about life-long immunity. As covid has a 99% survival rate and we do not have effective anti-viral drugs, it is the person's own antibodies that are defeating it.

We are not talking about 100% absolute certainties here because we do not have that either way. In the meantime, "expert opinion" is the best you've got.
 

Back
Top Bottom