Buddy Skills - remaining vigilant !

Please register or login

Welcome to ScubaBoard, the world's largest scuba diving community. Registration is not required to read the forums, but we encourage you to join. Joining has its benefits and enables you to participate in the discussions.

Benefits of registering include

  • Ability to post and comment on topics and discussions.
  • A Free photo gallery to share your dive photos with the world.
  • You can make this box go away

Joining is quick and easy. Log in or Register now!

Phil_C

Contributor
Scuba Instructor
Divemaster
Messages
934
Reaction score
421
Location
UK, Middle East, Cyprus
# of dives
1000 - 2499
I have been pondering whether or how to post this since it happened last weekend, but I learnt from it, and it may help others think about the risks - so here goes.


I thought I was a safe diver until I recently had an experience on a very benign dive that has made me think about safety on a couple of levels.


Here is the scenario - a club dive (BSAC in the UK) so we had a surface marshall on shore and a safety diver in the water at all times, at a private inland quarry site with a maximum depth of about 17 metres/58 foot. It has a very silty bottom, and after a couple of divers have been in, if they have not been careful, the visibility can rapidly drop to zero. The club has unrestricted access every Sunday and on Wednesday evenings, so we dive there a lot and know the site very well.


The entry is from a landing stage into water about 1 metre/3 foot deep, it stays at this depth on a ledge for 2-3 metres/8 -10 foot, and then there is a slope that quickly descends to 9 metres/27 foot and after that it gradually goes down to 17 metres/58 foot, there are several boats, an aeroplane, bus and several cars in there, and numerous smaller attractions :)


I was diving with a 12 litre steel twinset, hood, gloves, drysuit etc. and had just finished a dive to the bottom which had lasted about 45 minutes in total, the weather was nice, it was sunny and felt quite warm and I was not cold. I thought I was relaxed and OK and chilled out after the dive.


At the end of the dive I started to de-kit in the water as usual, and was standing near the slope. Almost immediately I dropped my mask - the in water visibility was not good and the mask went straight down the slope - bum !


Never mind, I told the marshall what had happened, put on my spare mask, and made a slow descent down the slope searching for the mask, I made a quick search pattern and I found it, part way down, buried in the silt, which only took me 2 or 3 minutes of searching.


Ok - back to the surface to de-kit again, mask off, both masks stowed, careful not to drop it this time, fins off - drat - can you believe it I dropped a fin ! I have no idea why or what was wrong with me, I don’t normally drop anything, let alone twice in one dive. Guess what - it was a black fin, negative buoyancy - so yes, you’ve guessed it, it started to sink.


I’m not having this I thought - so immediately lunged down and grabbed for the fin - no problem, I caught it, but wait, don’t celebrate yet, a heavy steel twinset, leaning forward - yes you’ve seen it coming, I over balanced - and fell face first into three foot of water. No mask on, no regulator in my mouth, hands full of fins etc. and in water just too deep to put my arms down and push myself up.


Alright I know I had some different options, but I chose to roll onto my back and inflate my BC to push my face up out of the water, it worked. A very ungainly splutter and scramble to my feet later and I looked around fully expecting to hear the peals of laughter from my colleagues and dive buddy.


Now - this is what really disturbed me most, none of them had noticed a thing and were still blithely discussing their dives, the rugby or whatever other conversation took their fancy. Not one of them, the dive marshall, safety diver, or my buddy had seen what had happened or moved to help me.


They were not even standing ready to help, and laugh, if I had’t sorted myself out, because they hadn’t even noticed it happen.


So my two mistakes ? - my own complacency, at this site I de-kit in the water every week and just hand my fins and bits up onto the shore whilst I climb out, and I got sloppy, twice, and dropped kit, my anger at myself for being stupid twice made me forget the twinset and lunge for the fin putting myself off balance.


The second? - well clearly our buddy procedures had fallen apart or my buddy would have seen my fall and at least had a good laugh about it


If nothing else this brought home to me how the risks associated with diving don’t stop until you are safely out of the water and de-kitted, and really you still need to remain vigilant and aware of your buddy until you are.

Dive safe - Phil
 
I keep my mask on my face and my reg in my mouth until I get back to my car.

(Only slightly exaggerating.)
 
I've dropped my black negative fin twice. I remove mask & reg after on land (or boat). I never put MOF...........
 
Good recount, and thanks for the warning. I'm guessing your mates just didn't see the need to pay attention, or if they were, thought it was a normal, if shallow, lean-forward shore entry.

That temptation to "just pop down there real quick" is strong. You reacted by *doing something* rather than panicking, which got you breathing when freezing on the spot, wouldn't.

Lesson? Tell your buddies, "hey, I'm going in for a sec to grab (whatever), keep an eye out". Might make all the difference.
 
Good recount, and thanks for the warning. I'm guessing your mates just didn't see the need to pay attention, or if they were, thought it was a normal, if shallow, lean-forward shore entry.

That temptation to "just pop down there real quick" is strong. You reacted by *doing something* rather than panicking, which got you breathing when freezing on the spot, wouldn't.

Lesson? Tell your buddies, "hey, I'm going in for a sec to grab (whatever), keep an eye out". Might make all the difference.

I wish :) - Sadly no, it was a very a definite face plant :facepalm: ! - I had told them I was going down after the mask, and they had watched the bubbles until I came back up, it was when I was standing in shallow water supposedly de-kitting that it all went wrong, I asked them afterwards and they just hadn't noticed, personally even more embarrassing as we take it in turns, and I often am the safety diver after my dive is finished so I am supposed to still be aware and watching myself!

Never mind - lesson learnt - P
 
Now that you make me think of it, many rebreather accidents I've read were basically the same story of how "I'm just going to pop down and test this" became "where did he go?".
 
I always keep my reg in my mouth and mask on until safely back on boat and far enough from the water that I can't accidently fall in. It just seems like a safer thing to do.
 
Sorry to hear about the disappointment. Out of curiosity, was the dive buddy someone you usually dive with? If he/she was a new one, then it might either need some getting used to or keep looking for a good one. I totally get your frustration. I got paired up with a diver with similar experience during a recent dive trip (we were both solo divers). That guy was far more interested in wandering off with his GoPro than staying close to his buddy, me. He never bothered to signal me when/where he was going, and too many times I turned to check upon him and he was 5-10 meters away from me and/or on the other side of a reef/wreck. He never checked on me for the 4/5 dives we did together.
 
Stuff like this happen all the time on shore dives at many California beaches.
California surf can sneak up on you and become quite treacherous. There have been many people get seriously hurt or killed right at the shoreline in unpredictable surf break zones. One thing we learn is to NEVER take your eyes off the ocean. I've seen people get rag dolled in three or four feet of water and get rolled, tumbled, lose gear, lose masks, lose fins, break bones, get banged up, lose their pride...
You're right, the dive doesn't really fully end until you and your buddy are safely and completely out of the water on dry land.
 
Stuff like this happen all the time on shore dives at many California beaches.
California surf can sneak up on you and become quite treacherous. There have been many people get seriously hurt or killed right at the shoreline in unpredictable surf break zones. One thing we learn is to NEVER take your eyes off the ocean. I've seen people get rag dolled in three or four feet of water and get rolled, tumbled, lose gear, lose masks, lose fins, break bones, get banged up, lose their pride...
You're right, the dive doesn't really fully end until you and your buddy are safely and completely out of the water on dry land.
I hear ya. I've dived a couple of times in nasty surf in New Jersey. But it's not about diving, it's about logic. I swam in rough surf since childhood, body surfed big waves off Long Island's South Shore and elsewhere like Jax Beach. I took my experience forward into diving when certified age 51. It's hard to believe anyone would be
seriously tumbled in any surf that was decent enough to enter to dive. Losing fins, masks, breaking bones-- holy sh!t. But what do I know.....
P.S. Once in a while I still body surf at age 61 and usually regret it...
 

Back
Top Bottom