the sharkman
Contributor
Personally, I liked Palancar Gardens. The most colorful of all the reefs I dove there. Yucab came a very close second! Paradise was my least favorite. Santa Rosa was cool as well, with nice swimthroughs. If none of them suit your fancy, a drive around the island will lead you to a few nice dives, usually charging you 25 pesos for a beer and 50 pesos for a margarita...