Ask A Cop!!! Post Your Questions Here!

Please register or login

Welcome to ScubaBoard, the world's largest scuba diving community. Registration is not required to read the forums, but we encourage you to join. Joining has its benefits and enables you to participate in the discussions.

Benefits of registering include

  • Ability to post and comment on topics and discussions.
  • A Free photo gallery to share your dive photos with the world.
  • You can make this box go away

Joining is quick and easy. Log in or Register now!

Wow! I can't believe how civil this thread has been so far.

Now, I'd like to add my own comments from a law enforcer's point of view. But first, the legal disclaimer:

My statements below are solely my own opinions in accordance with my rights under the First Amendment of the Constitution of the United States. These opinions may not reflect those of my employer.

how many DUI/DWI's does it take to actually go to jail? I see some people who have 2 and go to jail then there are others who have 8+ and still driving around. This will depend on your state. Some states are stricter than others when it comes to DUI enforcement. Sadly, in a few states DUI is not taken as seriously as it should be.

In California, if you are found to be in violation of 23152 of the California Vehicle Code (our DUI laws) you will likely be taken to jail. There is too much liability in letting someone who's had too much go home in a taxi, only to have the taxi driver turn around and then have our impaired driver get back into the car. Trust me, it's happened...

As far as to why they're out of jail, again that depends on the state. As to why they're still driving, very likely their licenses are suspended, but then again a lack of a license hasn't discouraged a lot of people who have NOT been arrested for DUI from operating a motor vehicle.

If you get a ticket and the officer checks off MVA (Motor Vehicle Act) in the top of the ticket but in the description of the violation (speeding) doesn't include MVA, the MVA section code for the specific violation or the amount of fine, even though there is a labeled box for it, does this mean the ticket is void? In other words - how can I be violating the MVA if there they didn't say which section of the MVA I violated? How can I pay the fine when the fine section has been left blank? Is it a warning ticket even though it's not written on the official warning paper and instead is on official violation paper? That's going to depend on your local laws and your local court. In my area, an error like that won't necessarily void your ticket out. Heck, I just got one kicked back that I FORGOT TO SIGN!! But rather than void the ticket out, the court clerk simply kicked it back with a nasty-gram attached telling me to sign it.

What firearm do you use? Sig-Sauer P-220 chambered for .45 ACP

Have you ever shot someone? No, but a couple of times I came REAL close.

When you were a kid, did you want to be a cop? HECK NO! This was the LAST job I would have wanted to do when I was a kid. Funny how things change as we mature.

Would you enforce an UnConstitutional law? Of course not, it would be illegal for us to do so. Remember though, a law isn't considered unconstitutional unless an appellate court says it is.

How often do you practice with your weapon? Depends on the agency. Mine makes us do range qualifications every two months. Of course we are encouraged to visit the range as much as possible.

What's the most funniest situation you've experienced? Far too many to recall. I do remember the non-English speaking guy trying to report someone trying to break in his house at night, while I'm trying not to laugh at his t-shirt which said "Warning: I have PMS."

What's the most embarassing situation you've experienced? I'm going to invoke my Fifth Amendment rights on that one :D

Don't leave home without one (in regards to radar detector possession) Legal or not, in my opinion they are largely useless. I can't tell you how many people I've cited for speeding who had one mounted to their windshield or sun visor.

My older brother has had one for years. Who in my family (which includes four siblings, two of whose offspring now have drivers' licences) has the most speeding tickets? Yup, the one with the radar detector...

What is the purpose of speeding tickets? To increase safety or to raise revenue?

Well of course it's to increase safety. If it doesn't hit you in the pocket book, how else are you supposed to be deterred from doing it?

Now, I'm not going to be naive and tell you that there isn't money in speeding tickets, because obviously there is. I will say that at least in CA, municipalities get very little revenue from speeding tickets, or any citations written for violations of the California Vehicle Code (where almost all of your driving laws can be found in this state). Sacramento gets most of the money. So for CA residents anyway, if you're unhappy with this, you might want to have a chat with Uncle Ahhnohld.

What is the point of having a law for front liscence plates , window tint, only allowing lane splitting on motorcycles in one state. Motorcycles should be able to cruise buy while the yuppies are trapt in traffic in there gas guzzeling SUVs. What is the point of patroling a deserted road in the middle of no where and pulling the one drivier in a hour, over for speeding. Why don't all states have "while children are present "signs in school zones , is it just to make more money thru out the day You might want to rephrase that, preferably in a one-question-at-a-time way. It sounds like what some lawyer tries to do to trip me up in court.

Where are all the good looking law enforcement officers? I thought we were all good looking. That's what they tell us in the academy. Now I'm hurt...

Is there an age limit for starting a career with the police in the US? This will vary by state and by department, but generally speaking age 21 tends to be the minimum across the country.

How long is the education before you starting working? Police academies can be anywhere from a month to as much as a year, with 6-7 months being the average.

The reason I'm asking (I'm in Norway) is that over here I see a "problem" in school broilers just out of high school and the military, with little or no work/life experience to bring with them into service. The students at the police academy here are very young! Not such a good thing, really. It's no different in the United States. The average patrol cop today is usually in his mid 20's or younger, this may be his first real job and is often still living with his parents. 30 years ago, the average patrol cop may have been in the same age group, but usually had military experience behind him.

It's become a real concern because a large number of cops were hired towards the end of, and right after, the Vietnam War and these officers are retiring in large numbers. You're not seeing the same level of experience as before.

What is the upper age limit to become a police officer in the US? Depends on the agency. We've hired officers that were in their 50's. Some agencies, by law, have upper age limits. Sometimes it's due to mandatory retirement ages (especially in Federal law enforcement) and if you hire too late, you won't have worked enough years to get a pension when you reach that age. Others, like the California Highway Patrol, have their hiring parameters actually spelled out in law (the California Vehicle Code in the CHP's case) which can only be changed by an act of the legislature and approved by the executive branch.

How do you qualify, and how long is the education/training? There is a selection process that varies, but usually involves a written test, a physical agility test, an oral board selection process, a comprehensive background investigation, a medical examination, and a psychological screening. As stated above, academies can be anywhere from 1 to 12 months long, with 6-7 months being commonplace.

Do you ever "badge out" fellow LEO's when they break the law? I'll answer it this way: have I given warnings to off-duty cops? Yes. But I also have given many warnings to ordinary civilians as well. I would say that for every cop I have let off with a warning, I have let 1000 more civilians go as well. And such warnings would only apply to minor traffic infractions; anything more serious like DUI or domestic violence, and my hands are tied.

How do you feel about lawyers and do you often get beaten in court? I personally don't like them, but dealing with them is part of the job. As far as being beaten in court, you can't let it get to you, it's also part of the job. However, I've gotten far more convictions than acquittals on my cases. With the acquittals I simply learn from my mistakes.

1) What goes on in a cops mind that makes him/her keep beating someone like Rodney King even after he has clearly given up? Well Diver0001, without getting into specifics, let's just say that it was a combination of poor techniques and letting your adrenaline do the thinking for you. Of course, until you have been in their situation, you can't really know what it's like.

2) And on a related question. Do cops brag about this kind of thing in the locker room? No, and you need to stop watching those really bad movies about how us mean cops are always scheming to violate some poor citizen's civil rights. Believe it or not, all we are interested in is going home in the same physical condition as when we arrived for work.

3) It seems to me that if the police have a constitutional monopoly on the use of violence against members of the public that people who enter the force should be screened for their ability to handle this power responsibly. Does this happen? If so, how is the screening done? Comprehensive background checks and psychological exams are part of the screening process.

(continued)
 
Have you guys seen Reno 911 ? Most of the show is really stupid and you won't want to watch it. but every now and then there are some really funny scenes in it making fun of cops. I got news for you mike...not only do most cops think it's hilariously funny (the field sobriety test scene is my personal favorite), but I wouldn't be surprised if some of the material doesn't come directly from real cops themselves.

OK, cop question!! Why does a cop follow right up on your tail gate for several miles before pulling you over? I have always wanted to slam on the brakes. This isn't just a Indiana thing either. We're probably trying to read the expiration tabs on your license plate. Or figure out just why you keep reaching under the seat...

Question: Do officers have yearly training and testing on the local laws and regulations they are enforcing? Many times (in a social setting), I have talked with officers and found their knowledge either cursory or out of date. I would think this is problematic when trying to conduct ones job. I realize an officer can't be an expert on the law or know every one but they should have a strong knowledge of the portion they are hired to enforce. Training and minimum test standards would be a good screening for who needs some refresher training. I’ve always been curious whether some are slipping through the cracks or training/testing is not conducted effectively.

The problem is that the laws change so frequently, it's near-impossible to keep up with them all. Remember it's not just changes in codified law (the law enacted by the legislatures) but also case law (changes in law or procedure as mandated by an appellate court) that we have to keep up with. Your head would literally spin if you had to try to keep up with these on your own, particularly with Search and Seizure. What keeps officers from being better updated is largely the cost of training them all on a yearly basis, so we do the next best thing is send a few to the training and then in turn they disseminate the information to the rest of us.

1.) Tazers: keep them or lose them? They have a place in the Use of Force Continuum, but are not the answer to everything.

2.) What are some pet peeves of yours when you pull someone over? (give us some tips of what not to do the next time we're pulled over) Aside from the usual not making sudden furtive moves for any place a firearm can be kept, my biggest peeves are with those who want to play Traffic Court by the side of the road. I will explain why I pulled you over, but if you don't agree with it, don't expect me to let you play Johnny Cochran wannabe while traffic is whizzing by only inches from my behind. The court date at the bottom of your ticket is the time and place for you to plead "Not Guilty."

On a related note, please don't think that dragging me to court "on my day off" is going to give me any heartburn, because it won't. I, like most officers, are paid to go to court even on our days off, and many prefer it on their day off because they get paid time and a half.

My grandfather passed away some years ago and I ended up with his handgun. Do I need a permit to own? Do I need some type of permit to keep in the dash or trunk of my auto? FYI - I had the gun disposed of since I had small kids at the time - but I always wondered about these issues! These are questions best posed to your local law enforcers, as gun laws vary across this country.

I'm not a LEO, never played one on TV but i did save a pile of money using Geico Actually, the line should read "I'm not a real cop, but I did stay at a Holiday Inn Express last night." Plus GEICO actually wanted to charge me $400 more EVERY SIX MONTHS than Allstate for my auto insurance, despite never having had a ticket and my last accident (non-fault) being over 10 years ago.

A friend of mine is a Federal Agent. Some years ago a Congress-person was on the "sticky foam" bandwagon as in she wanted sticky foam to replace handguns for LEO's. When she asked my friend what he thought of it, he had one of those moments of perfect mental clarity. His response: sure ma'am, i think its a great idea, as long you're the first one through the door carrying it. I saw something on the Discovery Channel years ago about this, and I have yet to hear of it actually being deployed on a wide scale basis.

Your friend's retort sums up this job best: Lots of people THINK they know how to do it, but when asked to do it themselves, would rather not.

How do you get the job done without taking or giving the crap that can be so prevalent during stops? You grow a thick skin with this job. That, and not donuts, are the reason why cops get heavier with age.

(continued)
 
Perhaps it is because BAC is not the last word on a persons ability to operate a motor vehicle. I've heard of BAC's over the limit where the defendant was not shown to be 'Under the influence'. I've also seen more cases where a person was under the legal BAC and was still convicted. Most states like California have a "presumed impairment" level, usually .08% to .10%, with the former becoming increasingly common. An officer only has to show the subject was operating a motor vehicle at or above this threshold; no proof of impairment is necessary. At lesser levels, or in the case of driving under the influence or drugs, the officer is required to prove impairment in addition to intoxication.

Other issues are proving accuracy, maintenance and calibration of the device. An operator can be called into question as well. Courts have pretty much taken "judicial notice" of the accuracy of such devices, and usually will do so with the calibration if done by a certified facility (and certificates are issued as proof of this that we bring into court). Where we are usually attacked by attorneys is in our training and operation of the device, and the maintenance of it.

What´s a BAC? Blood Alcohol Concentration

I would just like for the state to put some of this money back into the public trnaportation system. Oh please...you're from SoCal and you think people LIKE to use public transport here? Most of our major commuter rail projects are running below capacity. Just like the song goes "Nobody walks in LA."

What's your position on concealed carry, are you for it, against it, or indiferent? What laws would you like to see changed regarding concealed carry? I have to agree with TJcop, gun laws are only effective against those who choose to obey them. Crooks aren't particularly noted for their ability to follow any laws, much less gun laws.

How do you handle an officer with a godly arrogant attitude? You know the ones that talk down to you... ? I have had this occur several times when I had to call the police for legitimate business.. Call the station and ask to speak to the Watch Commander.

Why do police officers in patrol cars not have to follow traffic rules? There are many reasons for this leesa. Occasionally, it is an officer who simply thinks the law doesn't apply to him, but I can say it happens a lot less frequently than most people think. You can't catch crooks real well when you're driving by them at Mach 2 1/2.

More likely the officer is trying to get to a call quickly, but because of the way people drive, prefer not to drive "Code 3." Anybody who's driven a police car, or a fire truck, or an ambulance, will know that the biggest danger with driving Code 3 (lights and siren) is the unpredictability of the drivers around you. I can fill up this thread alone with horror stories of near-collisions with people who do stupid things in front of emergency vehicles. I personally know of several officers who have been permanently retired due to disabling injuries as a result of collisions while operating in Code 3 mode. The California Highway Patrol recently buried one of its own who died in a traffic collision while in Code 3 mode.

Actually , some of the new officers seem to have a swollen head. I had an issue where I controlled the emergency scene with lifeflight and the officer attempted to make decisions for my patient. I had to call in the supervisor to have him removed from the scene. apparently, he thought because he was a basic EMT that he could make the decisions. Let's not turn this thread into a peeing match between cops and firefighters/EMS. I can tell many stories about firefighters ruining many a crime scene when it wasn't necessary, and/or otherwise interfering with police officers.

In fact, even when running code 3 (lights and siren) cops are still supposed to obey all traffic laws. That may be in the case in your state, but in CA those lights and siren actually give me permission to break them. However, I still have to drive with "due regard" for the safety of others.

What gets determines whether you receive a warning or a citation? Lots of things, including the nature of the violation, how many times you've been cited for it before (I'm not going to warn you when DMV says you've been popped 4 times in the last 3 years for the same thing), and whether I am already needed at another location. It's usually a gut instinct as to whether I go one way or the other.

What is the best thing to keep you from getting a ticket other than not speeding? IE: Which radar detecter? Other things? Obeying the speed limit is the only true way. As I've already posted, radar detectors are largely useless devices. Also, having a red-colored car does NOT make you more vulnerable to tickets. I owned a red Toyota pickup for many years and I wasn't any more vulnerable than if I had chosen a different color. Same with my sister and her bright red Celica.

Is it true that an officer can be vocally disrepectful to you, but you can't respond in turn without being arrested? No, and as already stated there are court rulings to the contrary. However, if part of your First Amendment exercise involves interfering with the officer, or making threats to dissuade him/her from doing the job, or some other violation of the law, then you will be treated accordingly. Also, if you're going to be a jerk with me, don't expect me to ignore that missing front license plate, that cracked windshield, or that baggy of marijuana on the center console.

Here's my question. What book/movie/TV show (fiction, not COPS) best reflects what it's really like to be a police officer? (Please don't say, T.J. Hooker) What's wrong with TJ Hooker? You mean you don't enjoy the sight of Heather Locklear throwing her PR-24 at a fleeing suspect?

All joking aside, even COPS isn't that realistic, as it only focuses on things that make up a small percentage of the job. If COPS truly portrayed what we do most of the time, you'd be bored to tears.

As I said above, Reno 911 pretty well captures the humor of the job, along with Super Troopers. Although its portrayal of actual police tactics and training is unrealistic, "Police Academy" does portray well what kinds of people do end up in this job; EVERY department has its own "Tackleberry." Same with Barney Miller.

As far as situationals, Hill Street Blues did a pretty good job. So did Adam-12 (it's based on real calls handled by LAPD officers) and Police Story. There was a short-lived series in the mid 90's called "High Incident" which pretty accurately captured what it's like to be a modern SoCal suburban cop (it was filmed in the San Fernando Valley). So was another short-lived show from a couple of years ago called "Boomtown." The first couple of seasons of "Third Watch" did the same but then the writing turned awful.

UNrealistic cop shows? "CHiPs" had to be the worst, and real-life CHiPies today cringe at the mention of that show, or of Erik Estrada, or if they hear someone whistling that theme song. Other unrealistic shows include "Pacific Blue", "21 Jump Street", and any cop show or movie on the Lifetime channel.
 
RonDawg:
Tazers: keep them or lose them?" They have a place in the Use of Force Continuum, but are not the answer to everything.


i know a case here in Florida where two officers, each over 200 lbs, tazed
a 13-year old, 75lb girl who was already in the back seat of the squad car
(but wouldn't cooperate to be re-cuffed)

they tazed her three times, and she finally allowed the re-cuff.

what do you think about this use of the tazer?
 
But you have to be a US citizen, right?

(Just found this one, at this place)

-Any good diving up in Seward, Alaska?! :D



-Well trained Norwegian ex-military CO, getting a bit old for NAVY SEALS. But hangin' in there! It would have been exciting though...
 
ShakaZulu:
I think if you look at what the cops have to deal with, "scum of the earth on a daily basis", I can see why they all become "D" over time, but that said, I still don't like them. I have a difficult time complying to any rules, so I get to deal with them rather too often, or my laywer does.

PS. I also drive a Mustang, and that thing only starts to run properly at 85mph?

.....I still don't like them....

And I am sure that feeling you have gets communicated, so it becomes mutual! ;)

.....I have a difficult time complying to (sic) any rules.....:bonk:

We know that, Shaka. Trust me, we know that!:D

.....I also drive a Mustang, and that thing only starts to run properly at 85mph.....

That is one of the oldest ones in the book!! So how many times has your lawyer gotten your license back for you??:D
 
i know a case here in Florida where two officers, each over 200 lbs, tazed
a 13-year old, 75lb girl who was already in the back seat of the squad car
(but wouldn't cooperate to be re-cuffed)

they tazed her three times, and she finally allowed the re-cuff.

what do you think about this use of the tazer?


Without knowing the actual specifics of the call, I'll give an official-sounding "no comment." I will say though that just because someone is less than 1/2 your weight, doesn't mean they can't hurt you or kill you.

But you have to be a US citizen, right? Almost all departments do require US citizenship, but a few (LAPD in particular) will allow you to start the process if you are a legal resident alien and have already started the citizenship process.

So how many times has your lawyer gotten your license back for you?? I always laugh when someone brings in a lawyer for a mere traffic infraction. Even if they do get an acquittal, they just paid FAR more in legal fees than what the fine would have been with a guilty verdict!
 
Can you settle a debate? In Ohio is it legal for 18+ year old to ride in the bed of a pickup truck as long as they are inside the bed--not sitting on the sides where they will fall out. I can't find this information online.
Ber :lilbunny:
 
RonDawg:
Wow! I can't believe how civil this thread has been so far.

who knows, we could see you guys next time we're pulled over! :) But seriously, it's because you guys have answered all the questions (even the loaded ones) really well and informatively.

There's no doubt I don't agree with everything you're saying, but I respect and support you for what you do. Thanks again!


question: my cousin's a part-time LBC officer. I love his stories about pulling over celebrities. Have you ever had an experience with any celebrities or prominent community citizens?
 
chip104:
question: my cousin's a part-time LBC officer. I love his stories about pulling over celebrities. Have you ever had an experience with any celebrities or prominent community citizens?

Being in LA, you do run into celebrities every now and then. For privacy reasons I won't disclose who they were.
 

Back
Top Bottom