How many are there of you? If I were alone, I would spend the extra and fly direct, but if there were two or more of us (that I was paying for), I'd fly into Cancun. Time-wise you can count on 2-3 hours extra travel time each way. It's not hard to do, though, just a bit time-consuming. If I only had a short stay, I'd be more inclined to fly direct, too.
here is the ditty... to fly into Cancun.. do not take taxi.. or shuttle (combi)... they are rip offs. ask where the bus is.. (its around the corner and cost is maybe 5.00.. I forget exactly.)
however.. if there are a few of you it may be wise to split the taxi but negotiate the price BEFORE getting in... (it is wise to do that no matter where you are)... Cozumel is somewhat of an exception.. but still wise.
NOW.. here is the rub. if you get there too late.. you have to spend the night and take the ferry the next morning.. the last ferry to Cozumel is at 7PM or 8PM.. dont ask me why..
now, here is the return rub.. check your return flight.. if it is early in the morning.. you will have to go over the night (day) before to make your flight.. the first ferry leaves Cozumel about 8 or 9.
I tried to catch first ferry to Cozumel to make my dive and didnt arrive in time! what a BUMMER!!!!
the ferries recently got together and quit competing against each other.. they used to compete in price and race back and forth.. now there is no competition and the schedules have changed.. no Real early 6AM ferries and no late night ones.
so, do your homework.. plan the times.. and the ferries can be an excellent choice.. and PlayaCar is a great place to visit.. though it is now a mini-Cancun and a little too busy (for me).. I remember when I use to fly from Cozumel to PlayaCar... it was up and down and only 10 or 15.00.. and take taxi to Cancun for 15 or 20... it was up and down and only 10 or 15.00.
stayed at the Blue Parrot.. (the bird was red)... or was it the Red Parrot and the bird was blue... too many Margaritas back then.. anywho.. it was 25 a night.. now i think it is 250.00 after extensive remodel.. but give me the good old days.
have fun on your trip.. and read the good feeds on the food... if you go by Dive Paradise please say hello to Apple! she can also assist you with information for your travel. (google it)
dive Dive DIVE