Just my two cents......We've been going to CZM for the past ten (10) years. Because it is Mexico and an island, the food we crave is Mexican/Spanish (not Italian, American or other ethnic cuisines). Therefore Mexican/Spanish seafood is our goal. A few of the consistent quality and reasonably priced restaurants are as follows:
La Choza - Tasty, fresh food in a clean environment. The original location burned but, the new location is around the corner on 10th avenue.
Casa Mission - Good quality food in a beautiful home with surrounding gardens.
la Morena - Mexican food prepared with care and attention. Good desserts.
la Veranda - On this past trip (March 20-27), we had our best dinner experience here! The outdoor garden seating was beautiful. The food was exceptional. The classical (Norwegian) guitar player was excellent, personalble and not begging for tips. This restaurant will be our numero uno choice when we return on our next trip to CZM later this year.
Kinta - We think this restaurant is the best newcommer in San Miguel. On this past trip, the restaurant was closed for renovations/expansion.
These restaurants exhibit the charm and flavor of Cozumel and the Mexican culture and its cuisine. We never dress above the acceptable level of clean shirts and shorts and sandels/sneakers (remember - it is Mexico and the islands for Pete's sake!). Relax and enjoy new surrounding and tastes. Bon apetite!