lv2dive
Formerly known as KatePNAtl
Off the top of my head, I can think of two trimix *instructors* I've been in the water with, who looked like they themselves needed to go back to OW training. Like everyone else commenting, of course I shake my head at these situations, but I can easily accept that there are enough bad instructors out there, that there are bound to be several similarly-skilled (or rather, unskilled) hypoxic-certified divers who don’t even realize that they are lacking fundamental skills (never mind advanced skills required for hypoxic level certifications).
...As others have noted, Diver #1 looks like a newly certified OW diver at best. In fact, I would be embarrassed if one of my newly certified OW divers looked like that. If he did indeed show a trimix card, it had to have been faked. I cannot believe he ever even took such a class, let alone passed it...