It's not the Ritz. But comfortable, clean, with good food and superb diving service.
Perhaps most important, the staff on both the hotel and diving sides are extremely responsive to input.
@rsingler here is a recent news story involving Cobalt Coast that might be of minor interest. A serial burglar and addict hit the bar twice over 4 days to steal a total $185 CI in bar supplies to try and exchange for drugs. He has a long list of minor offenses and was out on a suspended sentence at the time of the robbery. The judge gave him a sentence of 2.5 years in prison, more to protect society from him than in the hope that he will rehabilitate himself. It's very sad, he probably knew that they had security cameras at the bar but he was driven by his addiction, but it's about time that he does some real jail time with his record IMO; I hope he gets some help while he's away.
Serial burglar jailed for 2½ years for bar break-in - Cayman Islands Headline News