That's what you would see with different battery capacities though. They would both last a fairly long time when still new and stored and not in use.That echoes my experience. On my currently rapidly discharging Teric it was fine in storage when I bought it until I went on a LOB. Then it developed the fast discharge in storage problem. Sent it in to be repaired and it was fine until I went on another LOB. Now it's rapidly discharging again in storage. My second Teric went on the same LOB as the first one in May and it seems fine. *shrug*
Once you start using and charging them, the cell with the worse capacity would seemingly age and lose capacity much faster.
As I said, you can only really check for capacity when you fully charge and let the device run until it dies. Ideally in a mode with the highest draw.
If two devices run the same length of time at the same temperature from full to empty but one of them discharges faster in storage, you know it's not a capacity issue. You can still try it.