If the coin ridges on the plastic cap have broken off, and the rest of the battery hatch cover looks OK, I have had excellent results by putting a mounded glob of PC Super Epoxy (can get on Amazon) over the broken coin slot, then when the epoxy starts to set up (clay like texture) , push a coin or screwdriver into the curing epoxy, giving you the size slot you want. When that epoxy fully cures, it is like a rock. I have removed. repaired, and replaced numerous plastic battery hatch covers on my two 2010 vintage Aeris Atmos AI computers, which I believe used the same hatch cover as the Sherwood Wisdom. I also have used an Aqualung I550 hatch cover (if you can find one), which I baked in an over to slightly change the thread, and then covered the slot with PC Super Epoxy as above. All of the modified battery hatch covers work as original. DM me if you need more info. A couple years ago, I posted a couple threads on extracting, repairing, and replacing those stupidly designed plastic battery hatch covers. One of the posts explains the baking process.