OMATICH
New
If you are talking about the SMBs one carries in a pocket then I agree with string. It's nuts to NOT have one attached to a spool.
And NEVER, EVER.. ( did you hear that?? ) attach it to oneself when deployed! NEVER..
For crying out-loud, it can't get easier or simpler to attach an SMB to a spool and stow it in a pocket. Hell, I have attached the same to a D-ring ( not deployed ) when diving a shorty with no pockets.
I really do feel everybody here is completely missing the way this should really be done. The plain rope is indeed by far the easiest, safest, simplest and most compact way to send up an SMB at 5m on your safety stop. All it takes is the understanding of the chain sinnet. The other half hitch knotting with the weight system is also incorrect, as all that you need is two quick releasing snaps of some sort and 5m of line. I personally use a dual snap like the one used in a finger spool and a yachting quick release snap shackle. I also have about a foot of shock cord or bungee to provide some elasticity. The way my system works is you tie the cord to the SMB using a simple knot, even a reef knot would do but i use a figure 8 with a lasso for cleaning the cord. A perfection knot or surgeons loop make suitable knots here too. I use paracord not the crap blind cord that comes with reels as it is a lot more manageable and durable, not to mention looks better. I then use perfection loops to attach the shock cord as they are the only loop knot that works with shock cord. Then another perfection loop onto my QR snap shackle. I then tie a tight sinnet with the paracord but not the bungee, starting at the bungee and working up to the SMB. When at the SMB you snap the double snap onto the last loop and pull it tight. This makes 5m into about 1, which wraps around the SMB nicely. Contrary to what most divers say as I am not using a useless snap I put the QR shackle on my shoulder d ring, unroll the cord and inflate the SMB. The sinnet stays done until you remove the double snap, which you do to release the SMB. No weight or cord trailing to the bottom, up goes the SMB pulling the sinnet undone as it goes. All this time I have my hand on the big lanyard I made for the QR shackle using a cobra braid, ready to release in the event of a snag (which does not happen with a sinnet, hence why you use them). You can then follow the line up and shove the cord into your pocket. SORTED. I may only be a novice but my passion for knots and lots of mountaineering have shown me that finger spools are crap for rec diving. If you are tech diving then get a decent reel. This works guaranteed. All the best, sorry you all got schooled by an OW with 16 dives. Hahaha...
P.S. I can post pics if you guys want. Also: take the ball off the dump valve and just tie a knot in the rope. folds up much nicer, less to break, works just as well.