So I got my Mares Puck Pro and the Suunto Zoop Novo today and just played around with them quite a bit. There's really not much more to do with them right now other than mess around with settings and stuff though lol.
The Mares Puck Pro was pretty easy to use regardless of it only having 1 button. It was pretty obvious what it did and how to use it, and navigating into the menus was easy. It was kind of a pain in the ass when I went to time, and had to cycle through the each time field and date when I tried to change to 12h from 24h. And I did it twice. But once I figured it out and saved the time, I didn't have to go back there. I definitely found the font and layout and stuff of some of the options very odd and hard to read. There was some stuff I flat out couldn't read and didn't know what it even meant.
Physically I found the strap hard to maneuver on this one. I found the plastic tooth that holds the watch in place was just kind of a pain to get in/out of the strap. It kept on getting caught when I didn't want to, and then pulling it out was kind of hard. I read that people said the strap was too short but for me it was more than long enough. I didn't have a wetsuit on but it would go over my 3mm easily with a lot of space to spare.
The screen as mentioned I found kind of hard to read on some screens, just due to the font and how they do the text. It was kind of weird changing the time where you see a "24h' options, and you press the button and it switches to "am/pm" and it's in really tiny font and it's in a different spot. Just things like that were kind of odd.
As for the Suunto Zoop Novo, it was also pretty easy to navigate around. Going through the options is obviously easier with the extra buttons being able to go back and forth and what not. I also found the font a lot easier to read on this one compared to the Puck Pro. I did notice as I pressed the buttons quite a bit that I was getting dimples in my thumbs, as you do kind of have to press down a bit, and with the plastic screen protector it makes pressing the buttons somewhat awkward due to the screen being a few inches off the base where the buttons are.
I found the screen on this overall to be nicer than the Puck Pro. It definitely seems bigger slightly and it is crisper. As mentioned the fonts were easier to read and it seemed a lot more uniform with how the text was. I also noticed that in the settings it had a 'secondary time' that the Puck Pro didn't, which I guess you would use just to set two different times if you are in on vacation in a different time zone and want to see the time back home. Not really a big deal at all just something I noticed.
While the strap on this is longer, it didn't really mater to me. I did find it easier to get this one on/off just because of the metal tooth on it (maybe that's why, but it was easier) and the extra part of the strap I kind of doubled back and put into one of the loops on the strap.
Aesthetically I like the Zoop Novo better. I also like the cleanliness of the screen on the Zoop Novo compared to how the Puck Pro is broken up into 3 different sections, although I understand and it makes sense. Without the sections I feel it makes the screen just have a cleaner feel, especially with the fonts being uniform. I heard people saying that the backlight on the Puck Pro wasn't as good but I don't know I couldn't tell much of a difference, they both did the job. I did see a video of someone showing the 'live dive log' thing that the Zoop Novo does too and thought that was really cool, but obviously I can't use that yet.
I'm going to play around with them a little bit more, well as much more as I can without doing a dive, but right now I'm definitely leaning towards keeping the Zoop Novo. It was like $296 with a coupon versus $159 for the Puck Pro, but if I like it better and feel better about it, it's worth it to me.