PLB for NE

[arkstorm]

So you’re saying the plb is better because it’s in someone’s pants pocket versus on their console? I’m not really sure I get your point. Both devices transmit your gps location via a satellite network afaik..

…Yes that is exactly what I’m saying…because if I find myself overboard, the rescue beacon in my pocket will be a lot more helpful then the one still sitting in the cup holder on the boat that is now speeding away from my position.

 

[Nick_Radov]

For those who don't know, an InReach is a satellite based two-way texting device that also has an SOS feature. You can communicate with the wives on shore, communicate with other boats when you don't want to broadcast information on an open VHF channel, get the weather, other features. It is subscription based (though I'm not sure if the SOS feature requires an active subscription). It uses rechargeable batteries that, depending on the device, last from as little as a few hours to as much as several days.

Garmin inReach devices communicate through the Iridium satellite constellation. The SOS feature requires an active subscription.

If the device is powered off then the rechargeable battery will last months. But then to use it you have to remove it from the dive case and turn it on. There's some risk of losing it if you do this while floating at the surface. Personally I leave mine powered on and clipped in my pocket while out on a boat. That way I could trigger an SOS via Bluetooth at the surface using my paired Garmin Descent dive computer. But leaving it powered on discharges the battery at up to 10% per hour while you're underwater because it continuously hunts for satellites, so for multi-day dive trips you'll need to recharge.

One benefit of the inReach is that it's really compact and can be used for other activities as well. I bring mine along whenever I go hiking/cycling/driving out of cell phone range.

 

[geordy]

In comparing a PLB vs InReach, I have sold them, flown in SAR aircraft, and am currently looking myself. With a PLB, my understanding is that it sends a 406mhz signal with the coordinates of your location when you pushed the button. It does not update that location. So if you are drifting, they may not be looking in the correct location. Some of the units may also put out a 121.5 VHF signal which can be homed in on, but I’m not sure how long it depletes the battery. I would assume no more than a couple hours at most.
The nice thing is that it works with multiple countries satellite systems. Outside of the US, I’m not sure how long it would take for responders to get into your area to search for you.

The inReach, though a subscription, I think is a little better. The key part is the gps sending updates on your location. It also allows you to send messages and receive them. Yes it goes to a commercial operations center, but they have years of experience now to work the bugs out of their system. It would still take time to get a response spun up, but they can be tracking you a bit easier.

I personally would prefer a PLB for over land and the InReach for water.

I welcome any responses that have different ideas about this.