johndiver999
Contributor
How does one expect to demonstrate competence in a rescue/emergency situation that can be expected to occur in rough water if the fins straps fall off in a mild turn in a pool? Why not adjust strap or use different gear?
Welcome to ScubaBoard, the world's largest scuba diving community. Registration is not required to read the forums, but we encourage you to join. Joining has its benefits and enables you to participate in the discussions.
Benefits of registering include
but those times are from swimmers who know how to execute a perfect turn. Most people don't. And turning and pushing with fines is quite different.
I would suggest that your full foot fins had plenty of power and contributed greatly to your faster than expected time. The only way to really tell is to do timed tests yourself.The full foot fin did not have that problem, but lacked power. Anyhow. I did it way faster than expected (in hindsight my normal fins would have been fine as well).
Yeah maybe. Although it were some cheap ass fins . But Yeah it went easy. And full foot definitely nicer in the pool.I would suggest that your full foot fins had plenty of power and contributed greatly to your faster than expected time. The only way to really tell is to do timed tests yourself.
What most divers think of as "power" is really initial acceleration, which is more pronounced with shorter and stiffer fins. That's nice if you need to make small and controlled movements, which is why such fins are popular for caves and wrecks. But these fins can't compete when it comes to top speed or maintaining a moderate speed for a long time (which may be why those jet fin divers prefer scooters when they have to get somewhere ). Also full foot fins are inherently more efficient as your muscles are more directly connected to the blades.
What is the requirement for the turn? competition turn, grab the end and start the other way without touching the bottom, reach the end stand and turn and keep going? Because if it's the first I'd wager a lot of people can't do it. I was a competitive swimmer for years, many, many, many moons ago. When I go to the pool (25m) was "continuous" swim involves getting to the end, grab the side, turn and keep going. I tried a competitive turn last time, it did not go well.That's not so much the point as the fact that when competitive swimmers do it, half a second matters a lot. SCUBA cert swims: not quite so much.
Maybe it's because I'm older, but the back strain to keep my head forward out of the water without using my arms would not last 800m. I'll bet everybody does it head in the water, which defeats the purpose of a rescue swim if you can't maintain visual contact.You can look forward just fine with a mask on. The lifeguard rescue swim does not use fins...so the arms become important.