ScubaFrog01:
Has anyone tried the nocturnal lights? I've been considering a canister light for some time now. Truth be told I don't know a thing about them. Why do some lights have twin light heads while other just have a single light head? Is there a true benefit either way? I'm looking at the TL50 Pro Rechargeable Dive Light, any input would be great.
NLI Tim mentioned something that seemed to address your last two questions. He mentioned "video" in his reply. If you light your subject (still or video) from only one side, you'll get some very stark shaddows. One of my buddies had one of his strobes fail on a dive trip, and he didn't have parts/tools to resolve it in Honduras. Although many over the pictures are
very cool with the shaddows, they weren't natural looking, and weren't what he was trying to record. (The attached photo isn't his best picture, but it is a good example of lighting from one side.) The Nocturnal Lights home page has an image of two lights on one camera tray. They're showing a canister light on one arm, and an SL50 on the other, but you'd get the idea.
...and for anyone who makes it through 12 pages of this post... it appears that you can still get a
15% discount at
www.nocturnallights.com for being a ScubaBoard member. Enter
scubaboard15 in the coupon window at checkout. It makes a really good offer, 15% better.
For my own next light purchase I'm trying to decide between the Nocturnal SL50 and the Brightstar 24. The Brightstar HID is supposed to be an awesomely bright light. (For the silly people reading this, perhaps you can tell me how to waterproof their
9x35w searchlight that puts out 28,800 lumens... which would be
bright!)
The Noctunal light comes with 3 bulbs, so it arrives pretty versatal. The folks at Nocturnal sell 3 different wattage bulbs, in two beam spreads, in two light color temperatures. Since they use a common design of bulb you can buy it in even more variations.
"Bulb Barn" (who I've never bought anything from, I just found it in a web search) shows MR16 bulbs with some incredible lumen numbers. So incredible, that I doubt they're true. For instance item #168 says that it puts out 10,000 lumens!
While researching batteries I found something that caused me a bit of concern about the Noctural lights. (If they offered a Goodman handle, I would not have been looking for parts to build my own light ...something for Nocturnal to consider.) The prices of batteries make me think there is no way I'd make my own, for enough less to make it a viable option (particularly with the 25% Demo discount,
and the 15% ScubaBoard discount) ...but
Battery Barn does not suggest using their similarly sized battery for halogen bulbs over 30 watts. (They say it's fine for an HID 50 watt light, because of the slower initial draw.) I don't know if/how Nocturnal overcame that hurdle, but perhaps that's one of the advantages of buying a complete (designed by professionals) light. ...not to mention that if I made my own light, it would look like a lump of PVC, and theirs looks so dang sexy.