I
idocsteve
Guest
It's getting hot in here.
Welcome to ScubaBoard, the world's largest scuba diving community. Registration is not required to read the forums, but we encourage you to join. Joining has its benefits and enables you to participate in the discussions.
Benefits of registering include
Concentrations??? Isn't 100% high enough No, but 200bar O2 would be a concetration
Fire triangle: O2 = Got it!
Fuel = A tank with silicone lubricant (hydrocarbon). Check!
Heat/Ignition Source = The heat created from the expanding aluminum. = Boom!
Why do you think the insurance is so high for any place that fills O2 tanks, and not just the scuba shops?
You're pretending that you can totally remove heat from the system. You can't. That's not reality. If you're trying to split hairs to sound smart, you're failing.
In real life, some heat DOES exist (during filling, opening the valve), and the tank really needs to be cleaned to mitigate that risk. Just get the damn tank cleaned, and be on your way.
In real life, if you for one moment think that an O2 clean tank, O2 clean transfill whip, O2 analyser or any other piece of equipment or particles in the air is going to stay 100% hydrocarbon free after a couple fills, you are fooling yourself BIG time!!!! Thus, is O2 clean kit really 100% clean all the time? I think not. Does each and every O2 clean tank blow up? Thank God not!!!!
Your equipment is not going to stay perfectly clean--but you try to keep it as clean as possible because there is no way of knowing without inspection how bad it is or what the threshold is.
No one is saying it is going to happen every time O2 hits a speck of contaminant, either.
This is very different from what you have been saying before, which is that it CAN'T happen. It certainly can, and it is a good idea to minimize those chances.
I am not pretending that heat can be removed. What I am suggesting is that less than80 degrees Fahrenheit is not going to be enough to ignite O2. Mitigate risk!!!!
This is very different from what you have been saying before, which is that it CAN'T happen. It certainly can, and it is a good idea to minimize those chances.
No matter how slow and even when you put a tank in a bath while filling it will still create heat. How much depends on the rate at which you fill. Do you really think that a tank doesnt expand under pressure???