I did a North-Brothers route and absolutely loved diving Brothers. Saw my first thresher shark and my first grey reef shark there. I also came face to face with a couple of oceanic whitetips in a memorable way: I was getting back on the zodiac at the end of ouir last dive at Brothers, and had handed up my gear and my camera, when the other diver on the Zodiac line said to me, "there's two sharks directly below us." I looked down and sure enough, there were two oceanic whitetips starting right at me, not more than 15 feet away. I instinctively and stupidly yelled to the zodiac tender to hand me my camera back, and the tender refused, and ordered me to get out of the water, which I did reluctantly. After the adrenaline rush had passed, I realized that the tender had done me a huge favor, at the risk of making a client unhappy -- and at the end of the trip I tipped him an extra $20 and told him it was for saving me from my own stupidity. Hanging out with a couple of oceanic white tips on snorkel at the surface is a special kind of stupid.
My first encounter with an oceanic white tip had actually been on a blackwater night dive in Kona, and the shark circled us for 20 minutes as we were tethered to the boat. That was memorable too.
View attachment 868958
All of which is to say, I do want to go back and do the BDE route.