Wow, thanks for all the great replies!!! I will be discussing this with my buddies on my upcoming dive trip.
BTW, when I did approach a no-stop time on one dive, it did not take me by surprise. I'm always monitoring my gauges. And what I did was something suggested above, I just didn't know if my reason for my signal would be understood: I got the DM's attention, pointed to my gauge, then to myself, and then gave a thumb-up. Out of a group of 8, there were only 4 of us still down, and I'd imagine all were getting close as well, and the DM brought the whole group up.
BTW, when I did approach a no-stop time on one dive, it did not take me by surprise. I'm always monitoring my gauges. And what I did was something suggested above, I just didn't know if my reason for my signal would be understood: I got the DM's attention, pointed to my gauge, then to myself, and then gave a thumb-up. Out of a group of 8, there were only 4 of us still down, and I'd imagine all were getting close as well, and the DM brought the whole group up.