I love wrecks. I know it is mainly because of my experience while serving in the US Navy but I like the history around the wrecks, the construction of the boats, the reason for its sinking, the eerie feeling of being around a wreck that was sunk due to mishap or weather, or both. I love it all.
I also like coral and fish and warm water. I like diving with colors other than green, gray or brown like we get at home. But after spending two weeks in Bonaire with all the reefs and fish I could ask for, I got a little bored. The Hilma Hooker was a fine wreck but one wreck to dive is not enough for me. We spiced it up by diving Salt Pier which gave me another man made structure to dive and while it was another great dive, its just not the same.
I need rusty metal or wooden slats in some sort of shape like a boat and I am happiest.
Key Largo is a great place for me to get the warm water and the wrecks at the same time. But since its a bit far to fill my fix, I will stick to the Great Lakes and doing what I can to dive here as often as possible.